Zhong Lichang, Shi Lin, Liu Xinpeng, Zhao Yanna, Gu Liping, Bai Wenkun, Zheng Yuanyi
Department of Ultrasound in Medicine, Shanghai Sixth People's Hospital Affiliated to Shanghai Jiao Tong University School of Medicine, Shanghai Institute of Ultrasound in Medicine, Shanghai, China.
Faculty of Chinese Medicine, Macau University of Science and Technology, Macau, China.
Gland Surg. 2025 Jul 31;14(7):1272-1282. doi: 10.21037/gs-2025-50. Epub 2025 Jul 28.
BACKGROUND: Current preoperative imaging methods, such as ultrasound, are limited by operator dependency and suboptimal sensitivity for detecting central lymph node metastasis (CLNM). This study aimed to propose a method that integrates deep learning and radiomics to accurately predict lymph node metastasis in thyroid cancer by analyzing intra- and peri-tumoral imaging features, thereby improving the preoperative prediction accuracy. METHODS: From July 2020 to June 2022, 405 patients diagnosed with PTC were enrolled from two centers: Center 1 (Shanghai Sixth People's Hospital) with 294 patients divided into a training set (n=294) and an internal validation set, and Center 2 (Tongji Hospital Affiliated to Tongji University) with 111 patients as the external test set. Postoperative pathological confirmation served as the reference standard for CLNM diagnosis. A total of 1,561 radiomics features and 2,048 deep learning features were extracted from intra- and peri-tumoral regions of each ultrasound image. Feature selection was performed using analysis of variance (ANOVA) and least absolute shrinkage and selection operator (LASSO), resulting in the selection of relevant features for constructing support vector machine (SVM) models. Additionally, radiomics-deep learning fusion models were developed by combining selected radiomics and deep learning features. RESULTS: Among 405 patients (mean age: 46.59±12.74 years; 68.6% female), 171 exhibited CLNM, highlighting the clinical urgency for accurate prediction. Among the 405 patients, 171 exhibited CLNM. The radiomics models demonstrated area under the curve (AUC) values of 0.760 in internal validation and 0.748 in the external test cohort. The deep learning models demonstrated improved performance with AUCs of 0.794 and 0.756 in the internal and external test sets. Notably, the highest AUC values of 0.897 (internal validation) and 0.881 (external test set) were obtained by the radiomics-deep learning fusion SVM model incorporating both intra- and peri-tumoral regions. DeLong's test confirmed statistically significant improvements (P<0.05) of the fusion model over the intra-tumoral radiomics model (P=0.008), intra-tumoral deep learning model (P=0.005), and combined intra-tumoral radiomics-deep learning model (P=0.01). However, no significant differences were observed compared to the combined intra- and peri-tumoral deep learning model (P=0.17). Decision curve analysis indicated that the fusion model offers greater clinical utility in predicting CLNM. CONCLUSIONS: The integration of radiomics and deep learning features significantly enhances the diagnostic performance for predicting CLNM in papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC). The radiomics-deep learning fusion SVM model outperforms individual radiomics and deep learning models, demonstrating substantial potential for clinical application in improving surgical decision-making and patient management. The fusion model could reduce unnecessary central lymph node dissections (CLNDs) and improve surgical planning by providing personalized risk stratification.
背景:当前的术前成像方法,如超声,受操作者依赖性限制,且在检测中央淋巴结转移(CLNM)方面敏感性欠佳。本研究旨在提出一种整合深度学习和放射组学的方法,通过分析肿瘤内及肿瘤周围的成像特征来准确预测甲状腺癌的淋巴结转移,从而提高术前预测准确性。 方法:2020年7月至2022年6月,从两个中心纳入405例诊断为PTC的患者:中心1(上海交通大学附属第六人民医院)有294例患者,分为训练集(n = 294)和内部验证集;中心2(同济大学附属同济医院)有111例患者作为外部测试集。术后病理确诊作为CLNM诊断的参考标准。从每个超声图像的肿瘤内及肿瘤周围区域提取了总共1561个放射组学特征和2048个深度学习特征。使用方差分析(ANOVA)和最小绝对收缩和选择算子(LASSO)进行特征选择,从而选择用于构建支持向量机(SVM)模型的相关特征。此外,通过结合选定的放射组学和深度学习特征开发了放射组学 - 深度学习融合模型。 结果:在405例患者(平均年龄:46.59±12.74岁;68.6%为女性)中,171例出现CLNM,凸显了准确预测的临床紧迫性。在405例患者中,171例出现CLNM。放射组学模型在内部验证中的曲线下面积(AUC)值为0.760,在外部测试队列中为0.748。深度学习模型在内部和外部测试集中的AUC分别为0.794和0.756,表现有所改善。值得注意的是,纳入肿瘤内及肿瘤周围区域的放射组学 - 深度学习融合SVM模型在内部验证中获得了最高的AUC值0.897,在外部测试集中为0.881。德龙检验证实融合模型相对于肿瘤内放射组学模型(P = 0.008)、肿瘤内深度学习模型(P = 0.005)以及肿瘤内放射组学 - 深度学习联合模型(P = 0.01)有统计学意义的显著改善(P < 0.05)。然而,与肿瘤内及肿瘤周围深度学习联合模型相比,未观察到显著差异(P = 0.17)。决策曲线分析表明融合模型在预测CLNM方面具有更大的临床实用性。 结论:放射组学和深度学习特征的整合显著提高了预测甲状腺乳头状癌(PTC)中CLNM的诊断性能。放射组学 - 深度学习融合SVM模型优于单独的放射组学和深度学习模型,在改善手术决策和患者管理的临床应用中显示出巨大潜力。融合模型可通过提供个性化风险分层减少不必要的中央淋巴结清扫(CLND)并改善手术规划。
Insights Imaging. 2023-12-20
Rev Esp Med Nucl Imagen Mol (Engl Ed). 2023