Luo Xin, Chen Gen, Zhang Shufeng, Hu Xuemei, Huang Chao
Radiology Department, Tongji Hospital, Tongji Medical College, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, China.
Quant Imaging Med Surg. 2025 Aug 1;15(8):7090-7100. doi: 10.21037/qims-2024-2526. Epub 2025 Jul 30.
Liver dynamic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (DCE-MRI) plays a critical role in detecting hepatic lesions but is highly susceptible to respiratory motion artifacts. Although advancements in rapid magnetic resonance (MR) acquisition techniques have been made, breath-hold acquisitions are predominantly used for abdominal DCE-MRI due to their superior image quality. Therefore, prescan breath-hold training is essential to improving patients' compliance and minimizing respiratory artifacts. Traditional oral training methods, which rely on operators monitoring chest/abdominal movement, are subjective and often insufficient for DCE-MRI requirements, leading to suboptimal image quality and potential risks from repeated contrast administration. To address these limitations, we developed a novel visual breath-hold training instrument and evaluated its efficacy in reducing respiratory artifacts.
This retrospective study included 174 patients undergoing liver DCE-MRI (pre-contrast, early arterial, late arterial, portal, and parenchymal phases). Patients were divided into two groups: the visualized breath-hold training (VBT) group (n=87) and the oral breath-hold training (OBT) group (n=87). In the VBT group, breath-hold training was performed with a self-designed visualized respiration training device. Operators objectively assessed training performance and provided individual guidance. In the OBT group, conventional training, with standard verbal instructions and tactile examination of the patients' chest and abdomen, was applied. For analyzing image quality, quantitative metrics [signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR)] and qualitative respiratory artifact scores were compared between groups with the Mann-Whitney test. For the comparison of diaphragmatic stability across sequential breath-holds, slice pages of the top or bottom of liver were recorded and analyzed via the Mann-Whitney test. A subgroup analysis was performed on non-contrast images from 18 patients, with respiratory artifacts being scored for paired intra-individual comparisons.
The VBT group had a significantly higher SNR and CNR than did the OBT group in the pre-contrast (SNR: P=0.018; CNR: P=0.006), late arterial (SNR: P=0.016; CNR: P=0.029), portal (SNR: P=0.003; CNR: P=0.002), and parenchymal phases (SNR: P=0.044; CNR: P=0.010). Respiratory artifact scores were lower in the VBT group across all phases (pre-contrast: P=0.021; early arterial: P=0.002; late arterial: P=0.001; portal: P<0.001; parenchymal: P<0.001). Diaphragmatic consistency during sequential breath-holds was significantly higher in the VBT group between the early arterial and portal phases (P=0.046) and the late arterial and portal phases (P=0.011) as compared to the OBT group. Intra-individual subgroup analysis further confirmed the reduction of artifacts in the pre-contrast phase scans (P=0.010).
VBT effectively reduces respiratory motion artifacts and enhances image quality in liver DCE-MRI by improving patient compliance. This approach holds promise for optimizing clinical workflows and diagnostic accuracy, especially in populations with limited breath-hold capacity.
肝脏动态对比增强磁共振成像(DCE-MRI)在检测肝脏病变中起着关键作用,但极易受到呼吸运动伪影的影响。尽管快速磁共振(MR)采集技术取得了进展,但由于其卓越的图像质量,屏气采集在腹部DCE-MRI中仍占主导地位。因此,预扫描屏气训练对于提高患者的依从性和减少呼吸伪影至关重要。传统的口头训练方法依赖于操作人员监测胸部/腹部运动,具有主观性,往往无法满足DCE-MRI的要求,导致图像质量欠佳以及重复注射造影剂带来的潜在风险。为解决这些局限性,我们开发了一种新型视觉屏气训练仪器,并评估了其在减少呼吸伪影方面的效果。
这项回顾性研究纳入了174例接受肝脏DCE-MRI检查(包括造影前、动脉早期、动脉晚期、门静脉期和实质期)的患者。患者被分为两组:视觉屏气训练(VBT)组(n = 87)和口头屏气训练(OBT)组(n = 87)。在VBT组中,使用自行设计的视觉呼吸训练设备进行屏气训练。操作人员客观评估训练表现并提供个性化指导。在OBT组中,采用常规训练,即标准的口头指令以及对患者胸部和腹部进行触觉检查。为分析图像质量,使用曼-惠特尼检验比较两组之间的定量指标[信噪比(SNR)和对比噪声比(CNR)]以及定性呼吸伪影评分。为比较连续屏气过程中膈肌的稳定性,记录肝脏顶部或底部的层面图像,并通过曼-惠特尼检验进行分析。对18例患者的非造影图像进行亚组分析,对呼吸伪影进行配对个体内比较评分。
在造影前(SNR:P = 0.018;CNR:P = 0.006)、动脉晚期(SNR:P = 0.016;CNR:P = 0.029)、门静脉期(SNR:P = 0.003;CNR:P = 0.002)和实质期(SNR:P = 0.044;CNR:P = 0.010),VBT组的SNR和CNR均显著高于OBT组。在所有阶段,VBT组的呼吸伪影评分均较低(造影前:P = 0.021;动脉早期:P = 0.002;动脉晚期:P = 0.001;门静脉期:P < 0.001;实质期:P < 0.001)。与OBT组相比,VBT组在动脉早期和门静脉期(P = 0.046)以及动脉晚期和门静脉期(P = 0.011)连续屏气过程中的膈肌一致性显著更高。个体内亚组分析进一步证实了造影前阶段扫描中伪影的减少(P = 0.010)。
VBT通过提高患者依从性,有效减少了肝脏DCE-MRI中的呼吸运动伪影并提高了图像质量。这种方法有望优化临床工作流程和诊断准确性,特别是在屏气能力有限的人群中。