Hou Ping, Feng Xiangnan, Chen Yan, Wang Xiaopeng, Jiang Yaojun, Liu Jie, Xu Chensi, Lyu Peijie, Zhou Zhigang, Gao Jianbo
Department of Radiology, The First Affiliated Hospital of Zhengzhou University, Zhengzhou, China.
Department of Statistics and Data Science, School of Management, Fudan University, Shanghai, China.
Quant Imaging Med Surg. 2025 Aug 1;15(8):7006-7018. doi: 10.21037/qims-2025-365. Epub 2025 Jul 24.
Contrast-enhanced computed tomography (CT) is essential for tumor assessment, but the detection of low-contrast liver lesions remains challenging. Reducing the radiation dose increases image noise, compromising image quality and diagnostic accuracy. Iterative reconstruction (IR) algorithms can reduce noise; however, they can also alter image texture and limit lesion detection. Deep-learning image reconstruction (DLIR) represents a promising alternative, but its efficacy in ultra-low-dose (ULD) hepatic CT for detecting small, low-contrast lesions remains underexplored. Thus, this study aimed to evaluate a novel real-time DLIR algorithm in ULD hepatic CT, focusing on image quality and lesion detection.
In total, 65 patients with hepatic lesions underwent both standard-dose and ULD abdominal CT scans during the portal venous phase. The standard-dose protocol (group A) used 120 kV with a signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of 1.0, and the images were reconstructed using 50% IR. The ULD protocol (group B) used 120 kV with an SNR of 0.5, and the images were reconstructed using 50% IR and 50% DLIR (groups B1 and B2, respectively). The quantitative and qualitative image quality parameters were assessed. The lesion detection rates were evaluated by lesion type and size using the metrics of detection rate, sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), and negative predictive value (NPV).
Group B showed a 73.3% reduction in the radiation dose compared to group A (1.5±0.8 . 6.9±2.0 mSv, P<0.001). Image noise differed significantly across the protocols: group B1 had the highest noise [10.05±2.94 Hounsfield units (HU)], followed by groups A (8.29±2.82 HU) and B2 (8.04±2.71 HU; all pairwise P<0.05 except group A . group B2: P=0.625). The CT values and contrast-to-noise ratios (CNRs) were comparable between groups B2 and A (all P>0.05), while group B2 had a 29.9-42.2% higher CNR than group B1 (all P<0.001). The qualitative assessments confirmed that the image quality and diagnostic acceptability of groups B2 (100%) and A (all P>0.05) were comparable, while the images of group B1 were diagnostically unacceptable (all scores <3). Overall, lesion detection was comparable in groups B2 (90.5%, 133/147) and A (98.0%, 144/147; P>0.05). However, group B2 had a significantly lower detection rate for small lesions (<0.5 cm: 77.8%, 42/54) compared to group A (P<0.05), but outperformed group B1 (57.4%, 31/54; P<0.05). Group B2 also had a significantly improved lesion detection rate and sensitivity for low-contrast lesions (87.2%, 95/109) compared to group B1 (75.2%, 82/109; P<0.05). The novel DLIR algorithm achieved a reconstruction speed of 60 images per second (ips), which was significantly faster than that of other DLIR approaches, while maintaining comparable performance to the IR algorithm.
The combination of tube current reduction with a novel real-time DLIR algorithm enabled ULD abdominal CT to achieve a 73.3% reduction in the radiation dose while maintaining image quality and diagnostic performance for detecting hepatic lesions larger than 0.5 cm.
对比增强计算机断层扫描(CT)对于肿瘤评估至关重要,但低对比度肝脏病变的检测仍然具有挑战性。降低辐射剂量会增加图像噪声,影响图像质量和诊断准确性。迭代重建(IR)算法可以减少噪声;然而,它们也会改变图像纹理并限制病变检测。深度学习图像重建(DLIR)是一种有前景的替代方法,但其在超低剂量(ULD)肝脏CT中检测小的、低对比度病变的功效仍未得到充分研究。因此,本研究旨在评估一种新型实时DLIR算法在ULD肝脏CT中的应用,重点关注图像质量和病变检测。
总共65例肝脏病变患者在门静脉期接受了标准剂量和ULD腹部CT扫描。标准剂量方案(A组)采用120 kV,信噪比(SNR)为1.0,图像使用50% IR重建。ULD方案(B组)采用120 kV,SNR为0.5,图像分别使用50% IR和50% DLIR重建(分别为B1组和B2组)。评估了定量和定性图像质量参数。使用检测率、灵敏度、特异性、阳性预测值(PPV)和阴性预测值(NPV)等指标,按病变类型和大小评估病变检测率。
与A组相比,B组的辐射剂量降低了73.3%(1.5±0.8对6.9±2.0 mSv,P<0.001)。各方案的图像噪声差异显著:B1组噪声最高[10.05±2.94亨氏单位(HU)],其次是A组(8.29±2.82 HU)和B2组(8.04±2.71 HU;除A组与B2组:P=0.625外,所有两两比较P<0.05)。B2组和A组的CT值和对比噪声比(CNR)相当(所有P>0.05),而B2组的CNR比B1组高29.9 - 42.2%(所有P<0.001)。定性评估证实,B2组(100%)和A组的图像质量和诊断可接受性相当(所有P>0.05),而B1组的图像在诊断上不可接受(所有评分<3)。总体而言,B2组(90.5%,133/147)和A组(98.0%,144/147;P>0.05)的病变检测相当。然而,与A组相比,B2组对小病变(<0.5 cm:77.8%,42/54)的检测率显著较低(P<0.05),但优于B1组(57.4%,31/54;P<0.05)。与B1组(75.2%,82/109)相比,B2组对低对比度病变的病变检测率和灵敏度也显著提高(87.2%,95/109;P<0.05)。新型DLIR算法的重建速度达到每秒60幅图像(ips),明显快于其他DLIR方法,同时保持了与IR算法相当的性能。
管电流降低与新型实时DLIR算法相结合,使ULD腹部CT在保持检测大于0.5 cm肝脏病变的图像质量和诊断性能的同时,辐射剂量降低了73.3%。