Suppr超能文献

“更多球员能够达到国家和国际水平”:教练对青少年壁球“年龄分组”的看法及其将相对年龄效应降至最低的潜力。

"More players can reach national and international levels": coaches perceptions of "birthday-banding" in youth squash and its potential for minimising relative age effects.

作者信息

Kelly Adam L, Shanmugaratnam Achuthan, Johnston Kathryn, Baker Joseph, Ferguson Matthew, Jeffreys Mark, Taylor Josh, McAuley Alexander B T

机构信息

Research for Athlete and Youth Sport Development (RAYSD) Lab, Research Centre for Life and Sport Sciences (CLaSS), College of Life Sciences, Birmingham City University, Birmingham, United Kingdom.

Tanenbaum Institute for Science in Sport, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.

出版信息

Front Sports Act Living. 2025 Jul 25;7:1618333. doi: 10.3389/fspor.2025.1618333. eCollection 2025.

Abstract

Relative age effects (RAEs) are common across many youth sports that use age group structures to band athletes. This creates a significant overrepresentation of those who are born near the start of the selection cut-off date across talent pathways compared to those born towards the end. In an attempt to identify, select, and develop the most talented squash players based upon their long-term potential, England Squash designed and implemented the "birthday-banding" approach (i.e., athletes compete with and against those of the same age and move up to their next birthdate group on their birthday), which has indicated promising results for moderating RAEs across their player pathway. However, little work has focused on the perceptions of interest-holders on this approach. For this reason, the purpose of this study was to use semi-structured interviews with fifteen England Squash Talent Pathway coaches, to better understand the mechanisms of the birthday-banding approach as well as its potential benefits and limitations. Using thematic analysis, three higher-order themes were found that comprised of six lower-order themes: (a) considering organisational structures (e.g., understanding selection processes, and reflecting on competition structures and performance outcomes), (b) building appropriate settings (e.g., promoting flexibility and fluidity in groups, and creating an environment that fosters long-term development), and (c) facilitating individual athlete development (e.g., encouraging holistic development and progression, and evaluating physical and skill development). Overall, coaches spoke highly of the implementation of birthday-banding, noting the value in creating fairness for athletes who might have been removed due to their birthday and maturation levels. Coaches also reported appreciating seeing athletes having varying competition within and across a year, as sometimes athletes would be relatively older and younger than their peers within the same 12 months. Some considerations and concerns were also raised about implementing a birthday-banding approach, which have been highlighted to inform continued improvements for both athletes and coaches in the system.

摘要

相对年龄效应(RAEs)在许多采用年龄分组结构来划分运动员的青少年体育运动中很常见。与出生在选拔截止日期临近末尾的运动员相比,这使得在整个人才培养路径中,出生在选拔截止日期开始附近的运动员明显占比过高。为了根据他们的长期潜力识别、选拔和培养最有天赋的壁球运动员,英国壁球协会设计并实施了“生日分组”方法(即运动员与同年龄的人竞争,在生日时升入下一个出生日期组),这在缓和其球员培养路径中的相对年龄效应方面显示出了有前景的结果。然而,很少有工作关注利益相关者对这种方法的看法。出于这个原因,本研究的目的是对15位英国壁球协会人才培养路径教练进行半结构化访谈,以更好地理解生日分组方法的机制及其潜在的好处和局限性。通过主题分析,发现了三个高阶主题,它们由六个低阶主题组成:(a)考虑组织结构(例如,理解选拔过程,反思竞赛结构和成绩结果),(b)营造合适的环境(例如,促进组内的灵活性和流动性,创造一个促进长期发展的环境),以及(c)促进运动员个人发展(例如,鼓励全面发展和进步,评估身体和技能发展)。总体而言,教练们对生日分组的实施评价很高,指出这对于那些可能因生日和成熟水平而被淘汰的运动员创造公平性具有价值。教练们还表示赞赏看到运动员在一年之内和不同年份有不同的竞争,因为有时运动员在同一12个月内相对于同龄人会相对年龄大一些或小一些。对于实施生日分组方法也提出了一些考虑因素和担忧,已强调这些以指导该系统中运动员和教练的持续改进。

https://cdn.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/blobs/bd3e/12333217/3c869b50c001/fspor-07-1618333-g001.jpg

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验