Magnuson Katherine A, Duncan Greg J, Yoshikawa Hirokazu, Yoo Paul Y, Han Sangdo, Gennetian Lisa A, Halpern-Meekin Sarah, Fox Nathan A, Noble Kimberly G
Sandra Rosenbaum School of Social Work, University of Wisconsin, Madsion, WI, USA.
School of Education, University of California, Irvine, CA, USA.
Nat Commun. 2025 Aug 13;16(1):7517. doi: 10.1038/s41467-025-62438-x.
This study examines causal impacts of unconditional cash transfers on economic hardship and key family processes that may affect children's development. The study randomized 1000 mothers of newborns, with prior-year household income below the federal poverty threshold, to receive unconditional cash transfers of $333 or $20 per month (Clinical Trial Registry number NCT03593356). Data collected approximately 12, 24 and 36 months after the child's birth show a moderate increase in household income and reductions in poverty; no statistically significant improvements in subjective economic hardship reports or quality of play with infants; and small, mostly statistically non-significant, increases in parental psychological distress and declines in mothers' relationship quality. However, mothers receiving the higher amount reported more frequently engaging in enriching child activities than mothers receiving the lower amount. Cash support may provide other benefits for families and children, but moderate support levels do not appear to address self-reported economic hardship or standard survey measures of maternal well-being. However, these results do not rule out the possibility of very small effects.
本研究考察了无条件现金转移对经济困难以及可能影响儿童发展的关键家庭过程的因果影响。该研究将1000名新生儿母亲随机分组,这些母亲上一年的家庭收入低于联邦贫困线,她们被随机分配每月领取333美元或20美元的无条件现金转移(临床试验注册号NCT03593356)。在孩子出生后约12、24和36个月收集的数据显示,家庭收入有适度增加,贫困状况有所减轻;主观经济困难报告或与婴儿玩耍质量方面没有统计学上的显著改善;父母心理困扰有小幅增加,且大多无统计学意义,母亲的关系质量有所下降。然而,领取较高金额的母亲比领取较低金额的母亲更频繁地报告参与了丰富孩子活动。现金支持可能为家庭和儿童带来其他益处,但适度的支持水平似乎并未解决自我报告的经济困难或衡量母亲幸福感的标准调查指标。不过,这些结果并不排除存在极小影响的可能性。