Suppr超能文献

人工智能在护理中的应用综述:教育、临床实践、工作量管理及专业认知

Integrative review of artificial intelligence applications in nursing: education, clinical practice, workload management, and professional perceptions.

作者信息

El Arab Rabie Adel, Al Moosa Omayma Abdulaziz, Sagbakken Mette, Ghannam Ahmed, Abuadas Fuad H, Somerville Joel, Al Mutair Abbas

机构信息

Almoosa College of Health Sciences, Alhasa, Saudi Arabia.

Department of Nursing and Health Promotion, Faculty of Health Sciences, Oslo Metropolitan University, Oslo, Norway.

出版信息

Front Public Health. 2025 Aug 1;13:1619378. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2025.1619378. eCollection 2025.

Abstract

BACKGROUND

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is rapidly transforming the nursing profession, presenting significant opportunities and challenges. Despite its promising potential in enhancing nursing education, clinical practice, and operational efficiency, critical barriers related to ethics, workforce adaptation, and humanistic care persist.

AIM

This integrative review systematically evaluates the integration of AI in nursing practice, with a specific focus on nursing education, clinical care, workload management, and professional perceptions.

METHODS

Guided by PRISMA 2020 and the SPIDER framework, a thematic synthesis was conducted. Study quality was assessed using the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT), and the risk of bias evaluated through ROBINS-I.

RESULTS

This review encompassed 25 studies, from which six overarching themes emerged.

EDUCATION AND TRAINING

AI-powered simulations and content-creation platforms enriched nursing curricula by presenting realistic clinical scenarios, which consistently yielded deeper student engagement, enhanced case-management performance, and higher satisfaction scores. Learners also reported an increased cognitive load and heightened stress levels when navigating these more complex, AI-driven activities.

CLINICAL DECISION SUPPORT AND MONITORING

AI-enabled alert algorithms and wearable sensors enabled nurses to detect subtle signs of patient deterioration and fever significantly earlier than conventional methods, supporting timelier clinical interventions. Qualitative feedback from critical-care staff underscores that these automated insights must be balanced with professional judgment to avoid overreliance.

REHABILITATION AND POSTOPERATIVE CARE

In neurosurgical, gynecological, and orthopaedic settings, AI-guided imaging tools and personalized follow-up pathways were linked to smoother recovery trajectories, streamlined follow-up processes and richer patient feedback, and exceptionally high patient satisfaction. Nurses noted that these technologies enhanced the precision of assessments without wholly replacing the need for human touch.

WORKLOAD AND WORKFLOW MANAGEMENT

AI systems that automated routine follow-up tasks and generated predictive workload models freed nurses from repetitive, non-clinical duties and offered data-driven insights to inform staffing decisions. These efficiencies allowed nursing teams to devote more time to direct patient care and were associated with reductions in burnout and improved workplace morale.

NURSING PERCEPTIONS

Across practice settings, nursing students and practicing nurses broadly welcomed AI's ability to streamline workflows and support decision-making, recognizing its potential to elevate patient care and professional practice.

ETHICAL IMPLICATIONS

Simultaneously, nurses voiced significant ethical concerns-chiefly around safeguarding patient data privacy, mitigating algorithmic bias, and preserving the compassionate, human-centered essence of nursing in an increasingly automated environment.

FRAMEWORK AND RECOMMENDATIONS

The Nursing AI Integration Roadmap (NAIIR) was developed, emphasizing transformational education, advanced clinical integration, ethical governance, robust organizational infrastructure, participatory design, and rigorous economic evaluation. This framework offers a structured, ethically informed, and user-centric approach, advocating for AI as complementary to human expertise.

CONCLUSION

Successfully integrating AI into nursing requires comprehensive strategic planning that addresses educational, clinical, ethical, organizational, participatory, and economic dimensions, reinforcing the core humanistic values of nursing. Of the 25 included studies, 21 were judged at moderate risk of bias; despite this limitation, evidence suggests improvements in critical thinking, learner engagement, and clinical satisfaction across diverse educational and practice settings.

摘要

背景

人工智能(AI)正在迅速改变护理行业,带来了重大机遇和挑战。尽管其在加强护理教育、临床实践和运营效率方面具有巨大潜力,但与伦理、劳动力适应和人文关怀相关的关键障碍依然存在。

目的

本综合综述系统地评估了人工智能在护理实践中的整合情况,特别关注护理教育、临床护理、工作量管理和专业认知。

方法

在PRISMA 2020和SPIDER框架的指导下,进行了主题综合分析。使用混合方法评估工具(MMAT)评估研究质量,并通过ROBINS-I评估偏倚风险。

结果

本综述涵盖25项研究,从中提炼出六个总体主题。

教育与培训

人工智能驱动的模拟和内容创作平台通过呈现逼真的临床场景丰富了护理课程,始终能让学生更深入地参与其中,提高病例管理表现,并获得更高的满意度评分。学习者还报告说,在进行这些更复杂的、由人工智能驱动的活动时,认知负荷增加,压力水平提高。

临床决策支持与监测

人工智能驱动的警报算法和可穿戴传感器使护士能够比传统方法更早地发现患者病情恶化和发烧的细微迹象,支持更及时的临床干预。重症监护人员的定性反馈强调,这些自动化的见解必须与专业判断相平衡,以避免过度依赖。

康复与术后护理

在神经外科、妇科和骨科环境中,人工智能引导的成像工具和个性化随访路径与更顺畅的康复轨迹、简化的随访流程、更丰富的患者反馈以及极高的患者满意度相关联。护士指出,这些技术提高了评估的准确性,但并没有完全取代人文关怀的需求。

工作量与工作流程管理

自动化常规随访任务并生成预测工作量模型的人工智能系统将护士从重复性的非临床工作中解放出来,并提供数据驱动的见解以指导人员配置决策。这些效率使护理团队能够将更多时间用于直接的患者护理,并与倦怠感的降低和工作场所士气的提高相关联。

护理认知

在各种实践环境中,护理专业学生和执业护士普遍欢迎人工智能简化工作流程和支持决策的能力,认识到其提升患者护理和专业实践的潜力。

伦理影响

同时,护士表达了重大的伦理担忧,主要围绕保护患者数据隐私、减轻算法偏见以及在日益自动化的环境中保持护理的同情心和以患者为中心的本质。

框架与建议

制定了护理人工智能整合路线图(NAIIR),强调变革性教育、先进的临床整合、伦理治理、强大的组织基础设施、参与式设计和严格的经济评估。该框架提供了一种结构化的、符合伦理的且以用户为中心的方法,倡导将人工智能作为人类专业知识的补充。

结论

成功将人工智能整合到护理中需要全面的战略规划,涵盖教育、临床、伦理、组织、参与式和经济等维度,强化护理的核心人文价值。在纳入的25项研究中,21项被判定存在中度偏倚风险;尽管存在这一局限性,但证据表明在不同的教育和实践环境中,批判性思维、学习者参与度和临床满意度都有所提高。

https://cdn.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/blobs/83e5/12354398/f82f9437082d/fpubh-13-1619378-g001.jpg

文献检索

告别复杂PubMed语法,用中文像聊天一样搜索,搜遍4000万医学文献。AI智能推荐,让科研检索更轻松。

立即免费搜索

文件翻译

保留排版,准确专业,支持PDF/Word/PPT等文件格式,支持 12+语言互译。

免费翻译文档

深度研究

AI帮你快速写综述,25分钟生成高质量综述,智能提取关键信息,辅助科研写作。

立即免费体验