Hopkinson Mike, Hendricks Sharief, Jones Ben, Nicholson Gareth, Patricios Jon S, Dane Kathryn, Gardner Andrew J, Howell David R, Owen Cameron, Quarrie Kenneth L, Tierney Gregory, Till Kevin, Wilson Fiona, Johnston Rich D
Carnegie Applied Rugby Research (CARR) centre, Leeds Beckett University Carnegie School of Sport, Leeds, West Yorkshire, UK
Carnegie Applied Rugby Research (CARR) centre, Leeds Beckett University Carnegie School of Sport, Leeds, West Yorkshire, UK.
Br J Sports Med. 2025 Aug 22. doi: 10.1136/bjsports-2024-108992.
To (1) systematically review the literature to identify which match-related risk factors and mechanisms of rugby tackle events result in musculoskeletal injury, concussion, head injury assessments, and head impacts or head accelerations; and (2) identify the perceived importance and feasibility of potential intervention strategies for tackle-related injury reduction in the rugby codes.A systematic search was performed using Preferred Reporting Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines. Risk factors/mechanisms associated with tackle injuries across the rugby codes were extracted. After extraction, 50 international rugby experts participated in a Delphi poll. Via content analysis, expert-recommended risk factors/mechanisms were developed. In round two, experts rated all risk factors and mechanisms for importance to injury risk. In round three, the feasibility of law changes, coach and player education, and training as interventions to reduce injury risk for each injury risk factor/mechanism deemed important during round two was rated.PubMed (MEDLINE), Scopus, SPORTDiscus (EBSCOhost) and CINAHL.Eligible studies included cohort, observational and cross-sectional designs, which included male or female rugby union, league or sevens players.37 eligible studies were identified, with 138 injury risk factors/mechanisms extracted. 70% of the studies were rated 'high quality', with 30% moderate quality. 38 new risk factors/mechanisms were recommended by the expert group, 8 being identified as important and highly feasible for modification by an intervention strategy. 'The tackler placing their head on the incorrect side of the ball carrier' was described as the most important mechanism, with 'training' and 'coach/player education' thought to be highly feasible interventions.Numerous risk factors or mechanisms associated with tackle-related injury appear important and modifiable, helping to guide interventions to reduce injury risk in the rugby tackle.
(1)系统回顾文献,以确定橄榄球擒抱动作中哪些与比赛相关的风险因素和机制会导致肌肉骨骼损伤、脑震荡、头部损伤评估以及头部撞击或头部加速;(2)确定在不同橄榄球比赛规则中,针对减少与擒抱相关损伤的潜在干预策略的重要性和可行性。采用《系统评价与Meta分析优先报告指南》进行系统检索。提取不同橄榄球比赛规则中与擒抱损伤相关的风险因素/机制。提取后,50名国际橄榄球专家参与了德尔菲调查。通过内容分析,制定了专家推荐的风险因素/机制。在第二轮中,专家们对所有风险因素和机制对损伤风险的重要性进行评分。在第三轮中,对在第二轮中被认为重要的每个损伤风险因素/机制,就法律变更、教练和球员教育以及训练作为降低损伤风险干预措施的可行性进行评分。
PubMed(医学期刊数据库)、Scopus、体育文摘数据库(EBSCOhost)和护理学与健康领域数据库。符合条件的研究包括队列研究、观察性研究和横断面研究,研究对象包括男子或女子英式橄榄球联合会、联盟式橄榄球或七人制橄榄球运动员。共确定了37项符合条件的研究,提取了138个损伤风险因素/机制。70%的研究被评为“高质量”,30%为中等质量。专家组推荐了38个新的风险因素/机制,其中8个被确定为通过干预策略进行修改很重要且高度可行。“擒抱者将头部置于持球队员错误一侧”被描述为最重要的机制,“训练”和“教练/球员教育”被认为是高度可行的干预措施。
许多与擒抱相关损伤的风险因素或机制似乎很重要且可改变,有助于指导采取干预措施以降低橄榄球擒抱动作中的损伤风险。