Baran Bartosz, Obidziński Michał, Hohol Mateusz
Mathematical Cognition and Learning Lab, Copernicus Center for Interdisciplinary Studies, Jagiellonian University, Krakow, Poland.
Front Behav Neurosci. 2025 Aug 4;19:1638374. doi: 10.3389/fnbeh.2025.1638374. eCollection 2025.
Despite miniature brains, insects exhibit flexible, adaptive, and goal-directed responses. Behaviors indicating rule abstraction and complex decision-making challenge the long-standing view of insects as rigid organisms limited to fixed reflexes. Here, we propose a new perspective: interpreting insect behavior through the lens of executive functions (EF). EF refers to a set of cognitive processes enabling behavioral control in situations requiring goal-directed action or adaptation to demanding conditions. Central among EF are inhibition (suppressing automatic, task-irrelevant responses), shifting (switching between strategies or rules), and updating (maintaining and revising relevant information), yet working memory, attention, planning, decision-making, and metacognition are also related to a widely understood set of EF. We argue that insect cognition can be productively reconsidered using the EF framework. Many behaviors documented in the literature align with EF components, even if not explicitly labeled as such. Others can be reinterpreted as EF-driven. Importantly, we show that EF-based interpretations support testable predictions: if executive control is involved, behavior should follow developmental trajectories, exhibit trade-offs between speed and accuracy, and adapt to changing contexts-patterns not expected from fixed heuristics or reflexes. Nonetheless, applying EF concepts to insects comes with challenges. Standard EF paradigms were originally developed to test human participants and often rely on language and explicit task instructions. Moreover, superficially flexible behaviors may still result from specialized, domain-specific routines rather than general cognitive control. Nevertheless, when used carefully, the EF perspective provides a structured, functional framework for studying insect cognition, enabling precise comparison across species with well-established concepts.
尽管昆虫的大脑很小,但它们表现出灵活、适应性强且目标导向的反应。表明规则抽象和复杂决策的行为挑战了长期以来将昆虫视为仅限于固定反射的僵化生物的观点。在此,我们提出一个新的视角:通过执行功能(EF)的视角来解释昆虫行为。执行功能是指在需要目标导向行动或适应苛刻条件的情况下实现行为控制的一组认知过程。执行功能的核心包括抑制(抑制自动的、与任务无关的反应)、转换(在策略或规则之间切换)和更新(维护和修订相关信息),然而工作记忆、注意力、规划、决策和元认知也与一组被广泛理解的执行功能相关。我们认为,使用执行功能框架可以有效地重新审视昆虫认知。文献中记录的许多行为与执行功能的组成部分相符,即使没有明确这样标记。其他行为可以重新解释为由执行功能驱动。重要的是,我们表明基于执行功能的解释支持可测试的预测:如果涉及执行控制,行为应遵循发展轨迹,在速度和准确性之间表现出权衡,并适应不断变化的环境——这是固定启发式或反射所无法预期的模式。尽管如此,将执行功能概念应用于昆虫也面临挑战。标准的执行功能范式最初是为测试人类参与者而开发的,通常依赖于语言和明确的任务指令。此外,表面上灵活的行为可能仍然是由专门的、特定领域的程序而非一般认知控制导致的。然而,谨慎使用时,执行功能视角为研究昆虫认知提供了一个结构化的功能框架,能够使用成熟的概念在不同物种之间进行精确比较。