Ostovari Mina, Crimp Natalie, Ratcliffe Sarah J, LeBaron Virginia
School of Nursing, University of Virginia (UVA), Charlottesville, VA 22903, United States.
School of Medicine, University of Virginia (UVA), Charlottesville, VA 22903, United States.
JAMIA Open. 2025 Aug 22;8(4):ooaf088. doi: 10.1093/jamiaopen/ooaf088. eCollection 2025 Aug.
Studies on symptom concordance between patients and their caregivers often use cross-sectional designs, which may fail to capture the longitudinal, dynamic symptom experience. The Behavioral and Environmental Sensing and Intervention for Cancer (BESI-C) is a remote health monitoring system that utilizes smartwatches and ecological momentary assessments (EMAs) to empower patients and caregivers to monitor and manage cancer pain at home. BESI-C collects real-time symptom data in naturalistic settings, enabling longitudinal tracking and analysis of symptom patterns over time.
To define and examine dyadic concordance using participant-initiated symptom reports collected via remote health monitoring.
Dyads of patients with advanced cancer and their family caregivers were recruited to use BESI-C for 2 weeks, reporting pain in real time through EMAs. We used Bangdiwala's B statistic to determine the concordance of patient-reported pain and caregiver-reported perceived patient pain under different contextual criteria (eg, co-location of participants; user engagement with BESI-C) that we hypothesized would impact concordance. We also explored a hypothesis that concordance would improve between study week 1 versus week 2.
Data from 21 patient-caregiver dyads were used for analysis. The reporting of pain events was highly variable between patients and their caregivers. Concordance of pain reporting improved when patients and caregivers were co-located and both wearing their BESI-C smartwatches. We did not observe consistent patterns in patient-caregiver concordance between week 1 and week 2.
We propose an analytical approach to define and evaluate concordance between patients' and caregivers' real-time symptom reports that can be applied to dyadic, longitudinal symptom data collected using remote health monitoring. Future work should examine the relationship between patient-caregiver symptom concordance with key quality-of-life metrics and sociodemographic factors that impact participant engagement with remote health monitoring technologies.
关于患者与其照护者之间症状一致性的研究通常采用横断面设计,这可能无法捕捉纵向的、动态的症状体验。癌症行为与环境感知及干预(BESI-C)是一种远程健康监测系统,它利用智能手表和生态瞬时评估(EMA),使患者和照护者能够在家中监测和管理癌症疼痛。BESI-C在自然环境中收集实时症状数据,能够对症状模式进行长期跟踪和分析。
使用通过远程健康监测收集的参与者发起的症状报告来定义和检验二元一致性。
招募晚期癌症患者及其家庭照护者组成二元组,使用BESI-C两周,通过EMA实时报告疼痛情况。我们使用邦迪瓦拉的B统计量来确定在不同情境标准(例如,参与者同处一地;用户与BESI-C的互动)下患者报告的疼痛与照护者报告的感知患者疼痛的一致性,我们假设这些情境标准会影响一致性。我们还探讨了一个假设,即研究第1周与第2周之间的一致性会有所改善。
来自21个患者-照护者二元组的数据用于分析。患者及其照护者之间疼痛事件的报告差异很大。当患者和照护者同处一地且都佩戴BESI-C智能手表时,疼痛报告的一致性有所提高。我们在第1周和第2周之间未观察到患者-照护者一致性的一致模式。
我们提出了一种分析方法来定义和评估患者与照护者实时症状报告之间的一致性,该方法可应用于使用远程健康监测收集的二元纵向症状数据。未来的工作应研究患者-照护者症状一致性与关键生活质量指标以及影响参与者对远程健康监测技术参与度的社会人口学因素之间的关系。