Aldersley Thomas, Ali Sulafa, Dawood Adila, Edwin Frank, Jenkins Kathy, Joachim Alexia, Lawrenson John, Reddy Darshan, Boumzebra Drissi, St Louis James D, Tchervenkov Christo, Verstappen Amy, Zheleva Bistra, Zühlke Liesl
Department of Paediatrics, University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa.
Division of Pediatric Cardiology, University of Khartoum, Khartoum, Sudan.
Cardiol Young. 2025 Sep;35(9):1782-1791. doi: 10.1017/S1047951125100504. Epub 2025 Aug 27.
There is geographic disparity in the provision of Pediatric and Congenital Heart Disease (PCHD) services; Africa accounts for only 1% of global cardiothoracic surgical capacity. Methods: We conducted a survey of PCHD services in Africa, to investigate institution and national-level resources for pediatric cardiology and cardiothoracic surgery. Results were compared with international guidelines for PCHD services and institutions were ranked by a composite score for low- and middle-income PCHD services. Results: There were 124 respondents from 96 institutions in 45 countries. Eighteen (40%) countries provided a full PCHD service including interventional cardiology and cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) cardiac surgery. Ten countries (22%) provided cardiac surgery services but no interventional cardiology service, 4 of which did not have CPB facilities. One provided interventional cardiology services but no cardiac surgery service. Ten countries (22%) had no PCHD service. There were 0.04 (interquartile range [IQR]: 0.00-0.13) pediatric cardiothoracic surgeons and 0.17 (IQR: 0.02-0.35) pediatric cardiologists per million population. No institution met all criteria for level 5 PCHD national referral centers, and 8/87 (9.2%) met the criteria for level 4 regional referral centers. Thirteen (29%) countries report both pediatric cardiology and cardiothoracic surgery fellowship training programs. Conclusions: Only 18 (40%) countries provided full PCHD services. The number of pediatric cardiologists and cardiothoracic surgeons is below international recommendations. Only Libya and Mauritius have the recommended 2 pediatric cardiologists per million population, and no country meets the recommended 1.25 cardiothoracic surgeons per million. There is a significant shortage of fellowship training programs which must be addressed if PCHD capacity is to be increased.
小儿及先天性心脏病(PCHD)服务的提供存在地域差异;非洲的心胸外科手术能力仅占全球的1%。方法:我们对非洲的PCHD服务进行了一项调查,以调查儿科心脏病学和心胸外科手术的机构及国家级资源。将结果与PCHD服务的国际指南进行比较,并根据低收入和中等收入PCHD服务的综合评分对机构进行排名。结果:来自45个国家96个机构的124名受访者参与了调查。18个(40%)国家提供全面的PCHD服务,包括介入心脏病学和体外循环(CPB)心脏手术。10个国家(22%)提供心脏手术服务但没有介入心脏病学服务,其中4个国家没有CPB设施。1个国家提供介入心脏病学服务但没有心脏手术服务。10个国家(22%)没有PCHD服务。每百万人口中有0.04名(四分位间距[IQR]:0.00 - 0.13)小儿心胸外科医生和0.17名(IQR:0.02 - 0.35)小儿心脏病学家。没有机构符合5级PCHD国家转诊中心的所有标准,8/87(9.2%)符合4级区域转诊中心的标准。13个(29%)国家报告了儿科心脏病学和心胸外科手术专科培训项目。结论:只有18个(40%)国家提供全面的PCHD服务。小儿心脏病学家和小儿心胸外科医生的数量低于国际建议。只有利比亚和毛里求斯达到了每百万人口2名小儿心脏病学家的建议标准,没有国家达到每百万人口1.25名心胸外科医生的建议标准。专科培训项目严重短缺,如果要提高PCHD治疗能力,这一问题必须得到解决。