Asher Robert J
Department of Zoology, University of Cambridge, Downing St., Cambridge, CB2 3EJ, UK.
Hist Philos Life Sci. 2025 Aug 27;47(3):42. doi: 10.1007/s40656-025-00691-5.
Ronald Aylmer Fisher (1890-1962) was a pioneer of evolutionary biology who founded modern statistics. He has often been associated with a gene-centric conception of natural selection, but he did not discount the importance of factors operating at other levels. In the later chapters of his 1930 book, The Genetical Theory of Natural Selection, Fisher proposed a mechanism to explain how a human civilization of any ethnicity could rise or fall. In contemporary terms, he did this by applying a concept of group selection, also known as "multi-level selection 1", in which supra-individual collectives impart consistent population structure over time to reproductive entities therein. Fisher believed that socioeconomic factors, operating above the individual level, could bias reproductive patterns and thereby have a causal influence on human social complexity. "Multi-level selection 2" is another kind of group selection which asserts heritable features to units above the level of the individual, and Fisher regarded "sexuality itself" as one such example. Fisher held some inaccurate views about human diversity, but appreciating how his argument foreshadows current multi-level selection theory does not require agreement with his mistakes. The chapters concerning human civilization in The Genetical Theory were not a polemic against non-Europeans, but reflected an understanding of multi-level selection and its effects on evolution as a whole.
罗纳德·艾尔默·费希尔(1890 - 1962)是进化生物学的先驱,他创立了现代统计学。他常常与以基因为中心的自然选择概念联系在一起,但他并不忽视在其他层面起作用的因素的重要性。在他1930年出版的《自然选择的遗传理论》一书的后几章中,费希尔提出了一种机制,用以解释任何种族的人类文明如何兴衰。用当代的术语来说,他是通过应用群体选择的概念来做到这一点的,群体选择也被称为“多层次选择1”,在这种选择中,超个体集体随着时间的推移赋予其中的生殖实体一致的种群结构。费希尔认为,在个体层面之上起作用的社会经济因素可能会使生殖模式产生偏差,从而对人类社会复杂性产生因果影响。“多层次选择2”是另一种群体选择,它认为个体层面之上的单位具有可遗传特征,费希尔将“性本身”视为这样一个例子。费希尔对人类多样性持有一些不准确的观点,但理解他的论点如何预示了当前的多层次选择理论并不需要认同他的错误。《遗传理论》中关于人类文明的章节并不是对非欧洲人的论战,而是反映了对多层次选择及其对整体进化的影响的一种理解。