Taha Mostafa Waleed, Fenwick Danielle J C, Marrs Emma C L, Chaudhry Abdul Shakoor
School of Natural and Environmental Sciences, Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne NE1 7RU, UK.
Microbiology Research Department, Freeman Hospital, Newcastle upon Tyne NE7 7DN, UK.
Microorganisms. 2025 Aug 19;13(8):1933. doi: 10.3390/microorganisms13081933.
Accurate label claims are essential for consumer trust in probiotic efficacy, yet limited datasets are available for poultry formulations marketed in the United Kingdom. We quantified and identified the viable bacteria in twelve commercial probiotics, seven for poultry and five for human use, using selective plate counts and MALDI-TOF MS. Observed colony forming units (CFU) were compared with declared values using one-sample -tests, adopting a practical acceptance range of ±0.5 log CFU. Poultry products largely met or exceeded their labels (e.g., P5: 1.4 × 10 CFU g vs. 2 × 10 CFU g declared), whereas human products delivered greater variability in both species composition and stated CFU count; one contained no detectable viable bacteria. All products deviated significantly from their label claims ( < 0.05); however, 11 of 12 met the ±0.5 log CFU benchmark-10 within the range and 1 above its "≥" value-leaving only one probiotic below the threshold. MALDI-TOF MS confirmed the presence of most labelled species, though was absent from one human product and isolates were re-assigned to /. These findings indicate robust quality assurance in UK poultry probiotics, but substantial under-delivery in the human probiotics, underscoring the need for harmonized viability standards and tighter post-market surveillance.
准确的标签声明对于消费者对益生菌功效的信任至关重要,但英国市场上销售的家禽用益生菌制剂的数据集有限。我们使用选择性平板计数法和基质辅助激光解吸电离飞行时间质谱(MALDI-TOF MS)对12种商业益生菌中的活菌进行了定量和鉴定,其中7种用于家禽,5种用于人类。使用单样本t检验将观察到的菌落形成单位(CFU)与声明值进行比较,采用±0.5 log CFU的实际接受范围。家禽产品大多达到或超过了其标签标注(例如,P5:1.4×10 CFU/g,而声明值为2×10 CFU/g),而人类产品在菌种组成和声明的CFU计数方面的变异性更大;有一种产品未检测到活菌。所有产品均与其标签声明有显著差异(P<0.05);然而,12种产品中有11种符合±0.5 log CFU的基准——10种在范围内,1种高于其“≥”值——只有一种益生菌低于阈值。MALDI-TOF MS证实了大多数标签标注菌种的存在,不过有一种人类产品中未检测到嗜酸乳杆菌,并且有一些分离株被重新归类为卷曲乳杆菌。这些发现表明英国家禽用益生菌有强大的质量保证,但人类用益生菌在活菌数量方面存在严重不足,凸显了统一活菌标准和加强上市后监管的必要性。