Sorokin Philip G
Moscow State Academy of Veterinary Medicine and Biotechnology - MVA Named After K. I. Skryabin, Moscow, Russia.
Appl Radiat Isot. 2025 Aug 12;226:112105. doi: 10.1016/j.apradiso.2025.112105.
Although some studies have investigated the accumulation of radionuclides in honey, other bee products such as wax and bee bread remain insufficiently studied, particularly in terms of seasonal and intra-seasonal dynamics. Spatial patterns of contamination within the foraging area of honey bees, as well as the role of botanical composition of nectar sources, also remain poorly understood. This study examines the dynamics of Cs and K accumulation along the pathway plant-bee-bee product on radioactively contaminated territories in the Bryansk Region during different periods of the honey flow. The results are compared with data collected at low-contamination sites in the Rostov Region. Samples of honey, capping wax, and nectariferous plants were collected in the villages of Vereshchaki and Katichi (Bryansk Region), as well as in the stanitsa of Vyoshenskaya (Rostov Region). The equivalent gamma-dose rate was also measured in the vicinity of the Bryansk apiaries. The activity concentrations of Cs and K in plants and bee products were determined using gamma spectrometry. Statistically significant differences in the activity concentration of Cs in honey samples from the Bryansk and Rostov regions were identified during different phases of the honey flow. In honey collected from contaminated areas (soil contamination density of Cs ranging from 185 to 555 kBq/m), the mean activity concentration of Cs was 44 ± 24 Bq/kg (range: 21-89 Bq/kg), significantly exceeding that of the control group. In capping wax, the mean activity concentration reached 56 ± 33 Bq/kg (range: 29-115 Bq/kg). Pollen analysis and direct foraging tracking linked notably elevated Cs activity concentrations in honey to nectar from Brassica spp. (rapeseed, field mustard), Phacelia tanacetifolia, Melilotus spp. (white/yellow sweet clover), Trifolium spp. (white/yellow clover), Centaurea spp. (cornflower, false-phrygian knapweed), Symphytum officinale (common comfrey), Filipendula ulmaria (meadowsweet), Calluna vulgaris (common heather), and Solidago virgaurea (European goldenrod), indicating the species-specific ability of these plants to accumulate radiocaesium and their potential as bioindicators of localized contamination hotspots. No statistically significant differences in the activity concentrations of K in honey were observed between the regions. Higher variability and greater accumulation of radionuclides were found in capping wax compared to honey, likely due to biophysical filtration processes and differences in the physicochemical properties of honey and wax matrices. Transfer factors for Cs and K along the pathway nectariferous plant-honey/wax were calculated. For Cs, arithmetic mean activity concentrations were used in the control group (homogeneous contamination), while weighted means were applied in the experimental groups (heterogeneous contamination) to account for spatial variability. A marked difference was found in Cs concentrations in plants between the experimental groups (237 Bq/kg) and the control group (45 Bq/kg), while the transfer factors for Cs remained consistent: 0.16-0.19 for honey and 0.24-0.44 for wax, suggesting the stability of these indicators under varying contamination conditions. The weighting of plant sample contributions was based on a digital area estimation of bee foraging zones, using pixel-wise analysis of masked regions on satellite imagery. Transfer factors for K were calculated using pooled samples due to its uniform distribution across all settlements, yielding values of 0.05 for honey and 0.19 for wax. Partitioning analysis in a modern hive system was conducted, reflecting the mass-based distribution of radionuclides within the trophic system of honey bees. These results advance understanding of radionuclide distribution in agroecosystems and confirm the effectiveness of using honey bees and bee products as bioindicators of radioactive contamination across territories with both high and low contamination densities.
尽管一些研究调查了放射性核素在蜂蜜中的积累情况,但其他蜂产品,如蜂蜡和蜂粮,仍未得到充分研究,特别是在季节性和季节内动态方面。蜜蜂觅食区域内的污染空间模式,以及花蜜来源的植物组成的作用,也仍然知之甚少。本研究考察了在布良斯克地区蜂蜜流不同时期,受放射性污染地区植物 - 蜜蜂 - 蜂产品路径上铯和钾的积累动态。将结果与在罗斯托夫地区低污染地点收集的数据进行比较。在韦列什恰基村和卡蒂奇村(布良斯克地区)以及维奥申斯卡亚村(罗斯托夫地区)采集了蜂蜜、封盖蜡和蜜源植物样本。还在布良斯克养蜂场附近测量了等效伽马剂量率。使用伽马能谱法测定植物和蜂产品中铯和钾的活度浓度。在蜂蜜流的不同阶段,确定了布良斯克和罗斯托夫地区蜂蜜样本中铯活度浓度的统计学显著差异。在从污染地区采集的蜂蜜(土壤铯污染密度为185至555 kBq/m)中,铯的平均活度浓度为44±24 Bq/kg(范围:21 - 89 Bq/kg),显著超过对照组。在封盖蜡中,平均活度浓度达到56±33 Bq/kg(范围:29 - 115 Bq/kg)。花粉分析和直接觅食追踪将蜂蜜中铯活度浓度的显著升高与十字花科植物(油菜、田芥菜)、天蓝苜蓿、草木樨属植物(白/黄花草木樨)三叶草属植物(白/黄花三叶草)、矢车菊属植物(矢车菊、假佛里吉亚矢车菊)、药用聚合草(普通聚合草)绣线菊(绣线菊)、帚石楠(普通石南)和高山一枝黄花(欧洲一枝黄花)的花蜜联系起来,表明这些植物积累放射性铯的物种特异性能力及其作为局部污染热点生物指示物的潜力。各地区蜂蜜中钾的活度浓度未观察到统计学显著差异。与蜂蜜相比,封盖蜡中发现放射性核素的变异性更高且积累更多,这可能是由于生物物理过滤过程以及蜂蜜和蜡基质物理化学性质的差异。计算了蜜源植物 - 蜂蜜/蜡路径上铯和钾的转移因子。对于铯,对照组(均匀污染)使用算术平均活度浓度,而实验组(非均匀污染)使用加权平均值以考虑空间变异性。发现实验组(237 Bq/kg)和对照组(45 Bq/kg)植物中的铯浓度存在显著差异,而铯的转移因子保持一致:蜂蜜为0.16 - 0.19,蜡为0.24 - 0.44,表明这些指标在不同污染条件下的稳定性。植物样本贡献权重基于对蜜蜂觅食区域的数字面积估计,使用卫星图像上掩膜区域的逐像素分析。由于钾在所有定居点分布均匀,使用合并样本计算钾的转移因子,蜂蜜为0.05,蜡为0.19。在现代蜂巢系统中进行了分配分析,反映了放射性核素在蜜蜂营养系统中的质量分布。这些结果推进了对农业生态系统中放射性核素分布的理解,并证实了使用蜜蜂和蜂产品作为高污染密度和低污染密度地区放射性污染生物指示物的有效性。