Gupta Shubhanshu, Sathe Sameer, Arya Kalpana, Mitra Bikramjeet, Mangeshkar Anil
Community Medicine, Government Medical College, Datia, IND.
Anatomy, Government Medical College, Datia, IND.
Cureus. 2025 Jul 28;17(7):e88879. doi: 10.7759/cureus.88879. eCollection 2025 Jul.
Introduction Integrated teaching methods are increasingly emphasized in medical education to bridge the gap between basic and clinical sciences, leading to early clinical reasoning and better learning outcomes. The study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of an integrated teaching-learning approach for Phase I MBBS students using the Kirkpatrick evaluation model. Methods This educational interventional study was conducted from September 2023 to August 2024 at Government Medical College, Datia, involving 150 Phase I MBBS students. Three core topics, Cardiac Cycle (Physiology), Heart (Anatomy), and Lipid Metabolism (Biochemistry), were covered through didactic lectures under an integrated teaching program. A pre-test and post-test design was employed to assess knowledge gain. The intervention was evaluated at three levels of the Kirkpatrick model: reaction (student satisfaction), learning (knowledge improvement), and behavior (student perceptions regarding program organization). Student feedback and faculty feedback were collected using non-validated structured questionnaires. Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and paired t-tests in Jamovi v2.3.28, with p < 0.05 considered statistically significant. Results Participants were 52% men and 48% women, with a mean age of 19.2 ± 1.1 years. Student feedback revealed high satisfaction, with the majority rating the sessions positively. Significant improvements were observed in post-test scores across all subjects (Anatomy: p = 0.036; Physiology: p = 0.001; Biochemistry: p = 0.004). Organizational aspects of the program were rated highly. Conclusion The integrated teaching approach effectively enhanced student satisfaction and learning outcomes. The findings support the inclusion of integrated teaching as a regular strategy in the medical curriculum to improve foundational learning.
引言 在医学教育中,综合教学方法越来越受到重视,以弥合基础科学与临床科学之间的差距,促进早期临床推理并取得更好的学习成果。本研究旨在使用柯克帕特里克评估模型评估针对医学学士一年级学生的综合教学方法的有效性。
方法 本教育干预研究于2023年9月至2024年8月在达蒂亚政府医学院进行,涉及150名医学学士一年级学生。在一个综合教学计划下,通过讲授式讲座涵盖了三个核心主题:心动周期(生理学)、心脏(解剖学)和脂质代谢(生物化学)。采用前测和后测设计来评估知识增益。在柯克帕特里克模型的三个层面评估干预措施:反应(学生满意度)、学习(知识提高)和行为(学生对课程组织的看法)。使用未经验证的结构化问卷收集学生反馈和教师反馈。在Jamovi v2.3.28中使用描述性统计和配对t检验分析数据,p < 0.05被认为具有统计学意义。
结果 参与者中男性占52%,女性占48%,平均年龄为19.2 ± 1.1岁。学生反馈显示高度满意,大多数人对课程给予了积极评价。所有科目在测试后的成绩都有显著提高(解剖学:p = 0.036;生理学:p = 0.001;生物化学:p = 0.004)。该课程的组织方面得到了高度评价。
结论 综合教学方法有效地提高了学生满意度和学习成果。这些发现支持将综合教学作为医学课程中的常规策略,以改善基础学习。