Yeom Ji Won, Lee Jung-Been, Park Soohyun, Cho Chul-Hyun, Lee Heon-Jeong
Department of Psychiatry, Korea University College of Medicine, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Chronobiology Institute, Korea University, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Brain Behav. 2025 Sep;15(9):e70834. doi: 10.1002/brb3.70834.
The Seasonal Pattern Assessment Questionnaire (SPAQ) evaluates seasonal variations in mood and behavior. According to Kasper's criteria, individuals meeting diagnostic standards for seasonal affective disorder (SAD) or subsyndromal SAD (S-SAD) are categorized as winter or summer type based on the month they "feel worst." However, in East Asian countries with hot, humid summers, relying solely on the "feel worst" item may misclassify seasonality. This study aimed to refine Kasper's criteria using machine learning to improve identification of winter-type seasonality.
Among 495 participants from a mood disorder cohort, SPAQ data from SAD and S-SAD cases were clustered using the K-Modes algorithm into winter type and other types. A decision tree algorithm identified winter seasonality with minimal SPAQ items.
Clustering aligned with additional SPAQ items beyond Kasper's criteria. Respondents selecting a winter month or "no particular month" as "feel worst" were classified as winter type if they also chose a winter month for "gain most weight," "sleep most," or "socialize least." Those selecting a summer month as "feel worst" were considered winter type if they marked a winter month for "gain most weight" or "sleep most."
This study evaluated seasonality in a South Korean early-onset mood disorder cohort using SPAQ and Kasper's criteria. Incorporating atypical vegetative symptoms and reduced social activity improved winter seasonality classification accuracy. The revised criteria may facilitate more precise identification and management of seasonal symptoms in East Asia.
季节性模式评估问卷(SPAQ)用于评估情绪和行为的季节性变化。根据卡斯珀标准,符合季节性情感障碍(SAD)或亚综合征性SAD(S-SAD)诊断标准的个体,根据其“感觉最糟”的月份被分类为冬季型或夏季型。然而,在夏季炎热潮湿的东亚国家,仅依靠“感觉最糟”这一项可能会对季节性进行错误分类。本研究旨在使用机器学习改进卡斯珀标准,以提高对冬季型季节性的识别。
在495名情绪障碍队列参与者中,使用K-Modes算法将SAD和S-SAD病例的SPAQ数据聚类为冬季型和其他类型。决策树算法使用最少的SPAQ项目识别冬季季节性。
聚类结果与卡斯珀标准之外的其他SPAQ项目一致。如果选择冬季月份或“无特定月份”作为“感觉最糟”的受访者,在“体重增加最多”、“睡眠最多”或“社交最少”中也选择了冬季月份,则被分类为冬季型。那些选择夏季月份作为“感觉最糟”的受访者,如果在“体重增加最多”或“睡眠最多”中选择了冬季月份,则被视为冬季型。
本研究使用SPAQ和卡斯珀标准评估了韩国早发性情绪障碍队列中的季节性。纳入非典型植物神经症状和社交活动减少可提高冬季季节性分类的准确性。修订后的标准可能有助于更精确地识别和管理东亚地区的季节性症状。