Parker Christopher S, Schroder Anna, Epstein Sean C, Cole James, Alexander Daniel C, Zhang Hui
UCL Hawkes Institute, Department of Computer Science, University College London, London, UK.
NMR Biomed. 2025 Oct;38(10):e70136. doi: 10.1002/nbm.70136.
Quantitative MR imaging with self-supervised deep learning promises fast and robust parameter estimation without the need for training labels. However, previous studies have reported significant bias in self-supervised parameter estimates as the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) decreases. A possible source of this bias may be the choice of the mean squared error (MSE) loss function for network training, which is incompatible with MR magnitude signals. To address this, we introduce the Rician likelihood loss for self-supervised learning, which explicitly accounts for the distribution of MR magnitude signals during training. We develop a stable and accurate numerical approximation of the negative log Rician (NLR) likelihood loss and compare its performance against the MSE loss using the intravoxel incoherent motion (IVIM) model as an exemplar. Parameter estimation performance was evaluated in simulated data and real data in terms of accuracy, precision and overall error by quantifying the bias, standard deviation and root mean squared error of network predictions against ground truth (or gold standard) values over a range of SNRs. Results show that self-supervised networks trained with the NLR loss have increased accuracy (reduced bias) of IVIM diffusion coefficient at low SNR, at the cost of reduced precision. As SNR increases, the performance of the NLR and MSE losses converges, resulting in estimates with higher accuracy, higher precision and lower total error. The NLR loss has potential for broad application in quantitative MR imaging by enabling more accurate parameter estimation from noisy data. The NLR loss is available as a Python package: https://pypi.org/project/RicianLoss.
利用自监督深度学习的定量磁共振成像有望实现快速且稳健的参数估计,而无需训练标签。然而,先前的研究报告称,随着信噪比(SNR)降低,自监督参数估计中存在显著偏差。这种偏差的一个可能来源可能是网络训练中均方误差(MSE)损失函数的选择,它与磁共振幅度信号不兼容。为了解决这个问题,我们引入了用于自监督学习的莱斯似然损失,它在训练期间明确考虑了磁共振幅度信号的分布。我们开发了负对数莱斯(NLR)似然损失的稳定且准确的数值近似,并以体素内不相干运动(IVIM)模型为例,将其性能与MSE损失进行比较。通过在一系列SNR范围内,通过量化网络预测相对于真实值(或金标准)的偏差、标准差和均方根误差,在模拟数据和真实数据中评估参数估计性能,包括准确性、精度和总体误差。结果表明,用NLR损失训练的自监督网络在低SNR下IVIM扩散系数的准确性有所提高(偏差降低),但精度有所降低。随着SNR增加,NLR和MSE损失的性能趋于一致,从而得到更高准确性、更高精度和更低总误差的估计值。NLR损失通过能够从噪声数据中进行更准确的参数估计,在定量磁共振成像中具有广泛应用的潜力。NLR损失作为一个Python包可用:https://pypi.org/project/RicianLoss 。