Gumiero Bruna, Veronesi Leonardo, Galgani Luisa, Cirrone Riccardo Gaetano, Corsi Alessio, Tafi Andrea, Loiselle Steven Arthur
CSGI - Consorzio Interuniversitario per lo Sviluppo dei Sistemi a Grande Interfase, Via della Lastruccia 3, 50019 Zona Osmannoro Firenze, Italy.
Università degli Studi di Bologna, Bologna, Italy.
Open Res Eur. 2025 Aug 20;5:45. doi: 10.12688/openreseurope.19162.3. eCollection 2025.
Citizen science plays a crucial role in advancing the objectives of the European Union's Water Framework Directive (WFD) and the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Among the key strengths of citizen science is that it fills information gaps in the management and observation of aquatic ecosystems, especially small rivers that often lack national and sub-national agency monitoring. The present study explores opportunities and challenges of integrating citizen science data with those of Environmental Agencies. The current state of the art is discussed through an analysis of 85 publications dealing with freshwater citizen science, finding that 34 of the ones individuated actually use citizen-science generated data. These 34 studies were analysed in more details focusing on data quality and geographical distribution. Findings highlight that citizen-generated data reach an accuracy between 70% and 90% when compared to laboratory values, but despite this outcome there is often lack of trust in citizen science data and processes. This is reflected in a limited involvement with policymakers and regulatory agencies. The present publication highlights good practices, challenges and opportunities for collaboration with environmental agencies, giving examples of some projects to address the WFD and increase the impact of freshwater citizen science.
公民科学在推进欧盟水框架指令(WFD)和联合国可持续发展目标(SDGs)方面发挥着关键作用。公民科学的关键优势之一在于,它填补了水生生态系统管理和观测方面的信息空白,尤其是那些往往缺乏国家和地方机构监测的小河流。本研究探讨了将公民科学数据与环境机构数据整合的机遇与挑战。通过对85篇关于淡水公民科学的出版物进行分析,讨论了当前的技术水平,发现其中34篇实际使用了公民科学产生的数据。对这34项研究进行了更详细的分析,重点关注数据质量和地理分布。研究结果表明,与实验室值相比,公民产生的数据准确率在70%至90%之间,但尽管如此,人们对公民科学数据和流程往往缺乏信任。这反映在与政策制定者和监管机构的有限参与上。本出版物强调了与环境机构合作的良好做法、挑战和机遇,并给出了一些应对水框架指令和提高淡水公民科学影响力的项目实例。