Hand Michelle D, Ihara Emily S, Moore Morgan, Shaw Madison
Department of Social Work, College of Public Health, George Mason University, Fairfax, VA, United States.
Front Hum Neurosci. 2025 Aug 26;19:1664304. doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2025.1664304. eCollection 2025.
Both music-related and nature-based therapeutic activities can enhance wellbeing, physical, social, emotional, and mental health, and recovery from posttraumatic stress. While music- and nature-based therapeutic approaches have been studied individually, research is limited on the holistic combination of music- and nature-based therapeutic interventions. Thus, a scoping review was conducted to chart primary research on the combined use of music- and nature-based therapeutic strategies and their effects on overall wellbeing, and within this scope, potentially on mental and behavioral health outcomes.
Included were peer-reviewed articles reporting primary research findings on how (if at all) the combined use of both music and nature-based interventions impacted wellbeing and thus, mental and behavioral health. All studies had to be reported in English. Excluded were studies that did not involve both nature-based and music-related therapeutic activities, those not involving primary research, and articles without a clear discussion on potential impacts on wellbeing, mental, or behavioral health. After applying this inclusion and exclusion criteria, 884 potentially relevant peer-reviewed articles were identified, 23 of which were preliminarily screened in upon abstract and title review. After full text reading, eight of these articles were deemed eligible for the review and were thematically analyzed.
Four themes were identified from the reviewed studies: (a) music- and nature-based activities yield benefits across various aspects of wellbeing, (b) multiple activities can be combined and adapted for diverse contexts and populations, (c) more research is needed on the combined therapeutic use of music and nature, and (d) choice and expression should be prioritized, which music and nature can facilitate. The primary focus of the reviewed studies was on how music-based interventions in outdoor or natural settings can impact multiple aspects of wellbeing, particularly emotional wellbeing, and with this, improved mood.
The results suggest that combining music and nature-based therapeutic approaches can improve mental and behavioral health by enhancing multiple aspects of wellbeing. For example, music-making in natural settings can foster deep connections with nature and spiritual wellness. Implications for future research are provided, as further research is needed on the combined use of music- and nature-based therapeutic activities.
与音乐相关和基于自然的治疗活动都可以增进幸福感、身心健康、社交、情感和心理健康,并有助于从创伤后应激中恢复。虽然基于音乐和基于自然的治疗方法已分别进行了研究,但关于音乐和自然治疗干预措施的整体结合的研究却很有限。因此,我们进行了一项范围综述,以梳理关于音乐和自然治疗策略联合使用及其对整体幸福感影响的初步研究,并在此范围内,探讨其对心理和行为健康结果的潜在影响。
纳入的是同行评审文章,这些文章报告了关于音乐和自然干预措施联合使用(若有)如何影响幸福感以及进而影响心理和行为健康的初步研究结果。所有研究必须以英文报告。排除的研究包括不涉及基于自然和与音乐相关的治疗活动的研究、不涉及初步研究的研究,以及未明确讨论对幸福感、心理或行为健康潜在影响的文章。应用此纳入和排除标准后,共识别出884篇可能相关的同行评审文章,其中23篇在摘要和标题评审时进行了初步筛选。全文阅读后,其中8篇文章被认为符合综述要求并进行了主题分析。
从综述研究中确定了四个主题:(a)基于音乐和自然的活动在幸福感的各个方面都有好处;(b)多种活动可以结合并适用于不同的背景和人群;(c)需要对音乐和自然的联合治疗用途进行更多研究;(d)应优先考虑选择和表达,而音乐和自然可以促进这一点。综述研究的主要重点是户外或自然环境中基于音乐的干预措施如何影响幸福感的多个方面,特别是情绪幸福感,并由此改善情绪。
结果表明,将音乐和基于自然的治疗方法相结合可以通过增进幸福感的多个方面来改善心理和行为健康。例如,在自然环境中制作音乐可以促进与自然的深度联系和精神健康。由于需要对音乐和自然治疗活动的联合使用进行进一步研究,因此给出了对未来研究的启示。