Gibbs Nick, Briggs Daniel
Northumbria University, Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom.
Front Sociol. 2025 Aug 25;10:1631118. doi: 10.3389/fsoc.2025.1631118. eCollection 2025.
The 'beautiful game' of football may seem to be a curious artifact of study for this scholarly collection on violence. However, this article will highlight the need to explore the boys' English youth academy (YA) football industry as a manifestation of systemic violence and, ultimately, a reflection of the pseudo-pacified neoliberal economy. Embedding our theoretical analysis within emerging literature on harm and violence, this paper will illuminate the dark underbelly of boys' elite-level youth football in England, examining the culture and relationships between academy players, YAs as breeding grounds for neoliberal subjectivities, the common practice of granting false hope to a 'supporting cast' of boys, and the underpinning inequalities in the elite academy industry. Drawing on data gleaned from thirty-five semi-structured interviews with current professional football practitioners and officials, as well as two former YA players, the work will provide a multifaceted analysis of the baked-in violence of the boys' youth academy system. We will argue that we ought to challenge the assumption of harmlessness that currently cloaks the systemic violence of the boys' elite game and move beyond , in favor of wholesale change.
对于这本关于暴力的学术文集而言,足球这项“美丽的运动”似乎是一个奇特的研究对象。然而,本文将强调有必要把英国男足青年学院(YA)足球产业视作系统性暴力的一种表现形式来进行探究,并且从根本上来说,它是新自由主义经济表面平静的一种反映。本文将理论分析置于关于伤害与暴力的新兴文献之中,以此揭示英格兰男足精英级青年足球运动的阴暗面,审视学院球员之间的文化与关系、作为新自由主义主体性温床的青年学院、给予一群男孩“配角”虚假希望的常见做法,以及精英学院产业中潜在的不平等现象。通过对35名现役职业足球从业者和官员以及两名前青年学院球员进行半结构化访谈所收集的数据,这项研究将对男足青年学院系统中固有的暴力进行多方面分析。我们认为,我们应当挑战当前掩盖男足精英赛事系统性暴力的无害性假设,并超越这种假设,转而支持全面变革。