Müller Fabian, Goudeau Sébastien, Stephens Nicole M, Aelenei Cristina, Sanitioso Rasyid Bo
Université Paris Cité, Laboratoire de Psychologie Sociale, Boulogne-Billancourt, France.
Centre de Recherches sur la Cognition et l'Apprentissage, CNRS, Université de Poitiers, Poitiers, France.
Int Rev Soc Psychol. 2023 Apr 20;36:3. doi: 10.5334/irsp.716. eCollection 2023.
The COVID-19 pandemic forced universities to move towards distance learning, requiring increased use of digital tools and more independent learning from students. In this context, the present study examined two previously documented barriers that contribute to social-class disparities in universities: the digital divide and the experience of cultural mismatch. refers to the disconnect between the highly independent cultural norms of universities and the interdependent cultural norms common among working-class students. Our goals are to (1) replicate the findings related to these barriers in a European context (2) provide pandemic-specific data related to these barriers, and (3) examine how the digital divide and cultural mismatch relate to psychological factors and learning behaviors necessary for academic success. Two thousand two hundred and seventy-five students in France answered questions about their digital access/use, self-construal, psychological factors (i.e., sense of belonging, self-efficacy, intentions to drop-out from the university), and learning behaviors (e.g., attending class, asking questions). Results showed that working-class students have less digital access and value interdependence more than their middle/upper-class peers, suggesting they are more likely to experience a cultural mismatch. Structural equation modeling revealed that both the digital divide and the experience of cultural mismatch undermines working-class students' psychological experience (e.g., belonging), which, in turn, hinders their learning behavior. The distance learning required by the pandemic led to increased needs for digital access and independence, and therefore more negatively affected working-class students, which could fuel and widen the social-class achievement gap.
新冠疫情迫使大学转向远程学习,这要求增加数字工具的使用,且学生要更加自主学习。在此背景下,本研究考察了两个先前已被记录的、导致大学社会阶层差异的障碍:数字鸿沟和文化不匹配经历。文化不匹配指的是大学高度自主的文化规范与工人阶级学生中常见的相互依存文化规范之间的脱节。我们的目标是:(1)在欧洲背景下复制与这些障碍相关的研究结果;(2)提供与这些障碍相关的特定于疫情的数据;(3)考察数字鸿沟和文化不匹配如何与学术成功所需的心理因素和学习行为相关联。法国的2275名学生回答了关于他们的数字接入/使用、自我建构、心理因素(即归属感、自我效能感、大学辍学意愿)和学习行为(如上课、提问)的问题。结果表明,与中/上层阶级同龄人相比,工人阶级学生的数字接入较少,且更看重相互依存,这表明他们更有可能经历文化不匹配。结构方程模型显示,数字鸿沟和文化不匹配经历都会损害工人阶级学生的心理体验(如归属感),进而阻碍他们的学习行为。疫情所需的远程学习导致对数字接入和自主性的需求增加,因此对工人阶级学生产生了更大的负面影响,这可能会加剧并扩大社会阶层成就差距。