Chae Taewoong, Chai Brandon S, Huang Adrian L
Faculty of Medicine, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada.
St. Paul's Hospital Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada.
JSES Int. 2025 May 2;9(4):1061-1068. doi: 10.1016/j.jseint.2025.04.006. eCollection 2025 Jul.
Social media platforms have become principal sources of information for patients to gather information before clinic visits. YouTube is a popular platform for educational videos, and since proximal humeral fractures (PHFs) are a common orthopedic trauma injury, this study aimed to assess the characteristics of YouTube videos on PHF and PHF treatment.
The terms "Proximal Humeral Fracture" and "Proximal Humeral Fracture Treatment" were used to gather the videos included in this study. Terms were searched programmatically using YouTube's search Application Program Interface. Top 50 videos from each search term were recorded and combined for a total of 100 videos. Duplicate videos were removed, and the remaining videos were rank ordered by the frequency and order of appearance from the initial search. Any non-English videos or videos irrelevant to the topic were excluded. The first 50 rank-order videos were included. Data collected were categorized into general parameters (eg, number of views, video length), source parameters (eg publisher affiliation, number of subscribers), and video content (eg, topic discussed, media type). Data were analyzed by 4 themes of basic information, information for health-care professionals, treatment, and rehabilitation. Each theme was further categorized by relevant subthemes.
Publisher affiliation of the PHF videos was most commonly commercial (56%). Health-care professionals or students were the more common target audience (62%) than patients (36%). The predominant media type used in the videos was lecture-style presentation (52%), followed by demonstration (32%), and interviews (18%). Sixty-two percent of the videos discussed basic information on PHF, such as epidemiology or mechanism of injury. Treatment and rehabilitation were the most popular themes, both discussed in 80% of the videos. Among the subthemes, imaging and operative were the most popular subthemes discussed, discussed in 50% and 58% of the videos, respectively.
As YouTube is one of the most popular platforms on the Internet, this study assessed the YouTube videos regarding PHFs and their treatment. This study found the PHF videos to cover diverse topics and to be relevant to both patients and health-care professionals. Hence, they can serve as a valuable resource for patients to supplement information they receive from their care provider. However, as YouTube is a largely unregulated platform, there is a need to advocate for content creation from credible sources such as health-care facilities or providers.
社交媒体平台已成为患者在门诊就诊前收集信息的主要来源。YouTube是一个热门的教育视频平台,由于肱骨近端骨折(PHF)是一种常见的骨科创伤性损伤,本研究旨在评估YouTube上关于PHF及PHF治疗的视频特点。
使用“肱骨近端骨折”和“肱骨近端骨折治疗”这两个术语来收集本研究纳入的视频。通过YouTube的搜索应用程序编程搜索这些术语。记录每个搜索词的前50个视频并合并,共得到100个视频。去除重复视频,其余视频按初始搜索中的出现频率和顺序进行排序。排除所有非英语视频或与主题无关的视频。纳入排名前50的视频。收集的数据分为一般参数(如观看次数、视频时长)、来源参数(如发布者所属机构、订阅者数量)和视频内容(如讨论的主题、媒体类型)。数据按基本信息、医护人员信息、治疗和康复4个主题进行分析。每个主题再进一步细分为相关子主题。
PHF视频的发布者所属机构最常见的是商业机构(56%)。医护人员或学生是比患者(36%)更常见的目标受众(62%)。视频中使用的主要媒体类型是讲座式演示(52%),其次是演示(32%)和访谈(18%)。62%的视频讨论了PHF的基本信息,如流行病学或损伤机制。治疗和康复是最受欢迎的主题,80%的视频都进行了讨论。在子主题中,影像学和手术是讨论最多的子主题,分别在50%和58%的视频中被提及。
由于YouTube是互联网上最受欢迎的平台之一,本研究评估了关于PHF及其治疗的YouTube视频。本研究发现PHF视频涵盖了各种主题,对患者和医护人员都有相关性。因此,它们可以作为患者补充从医护人员那里获得的信息的宝贵资源。然而,由于YouTube是一个基本上不受监管的平台,需要倡导由医疗保健机构或提供者等可靠来源创作内容。