Schwengerer Lukas
Institut für Philosophie, University of Graz, Heinrichstraße 26, Graz, Graz 8010 Austria.
Fakultät für Geisteswissenschaften, Institut für Philosophie, University of Duisburg-Essen, Universitätsstr. 12, Essen, 45141 Germany.
Asian J Philos. 2025;4(2):98. doi: 10.1007/s44204-025-00324-5. Epub 2025 Sep 17.
I develop an inferential account of collective self-knowledge. Starting with the assumption that groups have (at least propositional) attitudes I look at desiderata for any account of collective self-knowledge of such attitudes. Any such account has to explain the features that group avowals have in our ordinary linguistic practice. Moreover, any account ought to be compatible with as many views of group attitudes as possible. I propose a new account that looks at attitude-forming processes of groups as evidence for collective self-knowledge. It is based on forward-looking inferences in contrast to the backwards-looking conception commonly found in inferential accounts of self-knowledge in individuals. I then show that groups have a minimal form of privileged and peculiar access to their own attitudes because they have easy access to their own production of attitudes as evidence.
我提出了一种关于集体自我认知的推理式解释。从群体具有(至少是命题性)态度这一假设出发,我审视了对于此类态度的任何集体自我认知解释的 desiderata。任何这样的解释都必须说明群体宣称在我们日常语言实践中所具有的特征。此外,任何解释都应该与尽可能多的群体态度观点兼容。我提出了一种新的解释,将群体的态度形成过程视为集体自我认知的证据。它基于前瞻性推理,这与个体自我认知的推理式解释中常见的回顾性概念形成对比。然后我表明,群体对自身态度具有一种最低限度的特权性和独特性的认知途径,因为它们能够轻易地获取自身态度产生的证据。