Zhang Xiaofan, Liu Cheng-Wei, Sheng Xin, Jiang Yifan, Zhang Sheng, Mo XiaoYan, Yang Yuan, Ding Fengfei
Department of Pharmacology, School of Basic Medical Sciences, Shanghai Medical College, Fudan University, Shanghai 200032, China.
Department of Neurology, Tongji Hospital, Tongji Medical College, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430030, China.
Brain Commun. 2025 Aug 28;7(5):fcaf309. doi: 10.1093/braincomms/fcaf309. eCollection 2025.
Sleep deprivation paradigms have been employed in rat and mouse models to elucidate the function of sleep. The effects of sleep deprivation on memory function, as well as changes in depression- and anxiety-like behaviours, have been extensively investigated; however, the findings have often been inconsistent. In the present study, we conducted a comprehensive literature review of researches utilizing sleep deprivation paradigms in both rats and mice. A total of 164 original studies were analysed to extract results from behavioural tests concerning memory function and depression- and anxiety-like behaviours in wild-type rats or mice before and after sleep deprivation. The meta-analysis revealed that sleep deprivation consistently impaired memory function, irrespective of the paradigms, durations and species involved [ = 0.000, SMD (standardized mean difference) 95% CI (confidence intervals at 95%): -0.73 (-0.89, -0.57) for sleep deprivation; = 0.000, SMD (95% CI): -0.75 (-0.93, -0.57) for rapid eye movement sleep deprivation]. Similar, albeit less pronounced, effects were observed on depression-like behaviours [ = 0.000, SMD (95% CI): -0.41 (-0.52, -0.29) for sleep deprivation; = 0.000, SMD (95% CI): -0.60 (-0.79, -0.42) for rapid eye movement sleep deprivation]. The impact of sleep deprivation on anxiety-like behaviours was more variable. When considering both mice and rats, sleep deprivation generally exhibited anxiogenic effects [ = 0.049, SMD (95% CI): -0.19 (-0.39, -0.00) for sleep deprivation; = 0.705, SMD (95% CI): 0.04 (-0.18, 0.27) for rapid eye movement sleep deprivation]. However, subgroup analyses indicated that rodent species and sleep durations demonstrated distinct responses to sleep deprivation. This study provides critical insights for selecting optimal paradigms, durations, species and behavioural tests in experimental designs.
睡眠剥夺范式已被应用于大鼠和小鼠模型中,以阐明睡眠的功能。睡眠剥夺对记忆功能的影响以及抑郁样和焦虑样行为的变化已得到广泛研究;然而,研究结果往往并不一致。在本研究中,我们对利用大鼠和小鼠睡眠剥夺范式的研究进行了全面的文献综述。共分析了164项原始研究,以提取睡眠剥夺前后野生型大鼠或小鼠在记忆功能以及抑郁样和焦虑样行为方面的行为测试结果。荟萃分析表明,无论所涉及的范式、持续时间和物种如何,睡眠剥夺都会持续损害记忆功能[睡眠剥夺:P = 0.000,标准化均数差(SMD)95%置信区间(CI):-0.73(-0.89,-0.57);快速眼动睡眠剥夺:P = 0.000,SMD(95% CI):-0.75(-0.93,-0.57)]。在抑郁样行为方面也观察到了类似但不太明显的影响[睡眠剥夺:P = 0.000,SMD(95% CI):-0.41(-0.52,-0.29);快速眼动睡眠剥夺:P = 0.000,SMD(95% CI):-0.60(-0.79,-0.42)]。睡眠剥夺对焦虑样行为的影响则更具变异性。综合考虑小鼠和大鼠时,睡眠剥夺通常表现出致焦虑作用[睡眠剥夺:P = 0.049,SMD(95% CI):-0.19(-0.39,-0.00);快速眼动睡眠剥夺:P = 0.705,SMD(95% CI):0.04(-0.18,0.27)]。然而,亚组分析表明,啮齿动物物种和睡眠持续时间对睡眠剥夺表现出不同的反应。本研究为实验设计中选择最佳范式、持续时间、物种和行为测试提供了重要见解。