Hainline S, Myers L, McLelland R, Newell J, Grufferman S, Shingleton W
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1978 Jun;130(6):1157-8. doi: 10.2214/ajr.130.6.1157.
A study of 171 breast cancer cases matched by age and race to asymptomatic controls was undertaken to check Wolfe's assertion [1, 2] that breast cancer risk depends strongly on the mammographic classifications N1, P1, P2, and DY. The classifications were made blindly relative to all variables, including the case-control factor. Distribution of the four categories among the breast cancer patients in this study was consistent with the distribution found by Wolfe. (P = .46). Our age-standardized risk ratio estimates of the categories, relative to N1, are 1.5 for P1, 2.7 for P2, and 7.2 for DY. While not as striking as Wolfe's estimates, the same monotone trend is evident, and the cases and controls differ significantly with respect to the distributions of the four categories (P less than .01).
开展了一项针对171例乳腺癌病例的研究,这些病例在年龄和种族上与无症状对照相匹配,以检验沃尔夫的论断[1,2],即乳腺癌风险在很大程度上取决于乳房X线摄影分类N1、P1、P2和DY。这些分类是在不了解所有变量(包括病例对照因素)的情况下进行的。本研究中乳腺癌患者的这四类分布与沃尔夫发现的分布一致(P = 0.46)。相对于N1,我们对这些类别的年龄标准化风险比估计为:P1为1.5,P2为2.7,DY为7.2。虽然不如沃尔夫的估计那么显著,但相同的单调趋势很明显,并且病例和对照在这四类的分布上有显著差异(P小于0.01)。