Wergeland H
Acta Psychiatr Scand. 1979 Feb;59(2):218-28. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0447.1979.tb06962.x.
Eleven children who had received a diagnosis of elective mutism upon admission to the children's psychiatric clinic, were followed up 8--18 years later. The average age upon admission was 9 1/2 years, and at the time of follow-up, 23 years. Nine of the children came from homes with a strong familial shyness and reservation, and eight lived in social isolation. Six were particularly overprotected. Six came from discordant family constellations. All were diagnosed neurotic, eight specified as compulsion-neurosis. All were of normal intelligence. Six children received extensive individual psychotherapy (four upon admission to the clinic, two by way of out-patient treatment). We were unable to offer similar treatment to the remaining five. During the course of treatment three of the admitted patients improved, the fourth and the two ambulatory patients remained unchanged after up to 4 years of therapy. The follow-up study showed the three unchanged patients and the five who had received treatment, now were cured of the symptom; improvement took place in connection with a change of environment. The five who had not received treatment were better adjusted than those who had been separated from home for several years, at a vulnerable age. The importance of early prophylactic intervention is emphasized.
11名儿童在进入儿童精神科诊所时被诊断为选择性缄默症,8至18年后接受了随访。入院时的平均年龄为9.5岁,随访时为23岁。其中9名儿童来自有强烈家族性羞怯和内向的家庭,8名生活在社会隔离环境中。6名儿童受到过度保护。6名儿童来自关系不和谐的家庭组合。所有儿童均被诊断为神经症,8名被明确为强迫性神经症。所有儿童智力正常。6名儿童接受了广泛的个体心理治疗(4名在入院时接受治疗,2名通过门诊治疗)。我们无法为其余5名儿童提供类似治疗。在治疗过程中,3名入院患者病情好转,第4名患者以及2名门诊患者在长达4年的治疗后病情未变。随访研究显示,3名病情未变的患者以及5名接受过治疗的患者现在症状已治愈;症状改善与环境变化有关。5名未接受治疗的患者比那些在易受影响的年龄离开家数年的患者适应得更好。强调了早期预防性干预的重要性。