Burgoyne R W, Staples F R, Yamamoto J, Wolkon G H, Kline F
Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1979 Apr;36(4):400-3. doi: 10.1001/archpsyc.1979.01780040042004.
Three-hundred-twenty-five consecutive predominantly lower-class new patients at a psychiatric outpatient clinic rated the importance they attached to each of 14 categories of treatment needs or requests. Psychiatric residents subsequently rated the importance of each request for each patient at the conclusion of their initial assessment interview. Requests reflecting needs for intrapsychic therapy, clarification, and control of feelings were considered very important by approximately two thirds of the patients; needs for institutionalized contact, advice, and community triage by one half; and other requests for medication, reality contact, succorance, ventilation, confession, social intervention, administrative requests by a minority (one fourth to one third). Residents significantly underestimated the importance their patients attached to 10 of 14 requests. Factor analyses confirmed several systematic sources of disparity between patient and therapist perception of lower-class patient needs.
一家精神科门诊连续接待了325名主要来自下层社会的新患者,他们对14类治疗需求或请求的重要性进行了评分。精神科住院医生随后在初次评估访谈结束时,对每位患者的每项请求的重要性进行了评分。约三分之二的患者认为反映内心心理治疗、情感澄清和情感控制需求的请求非常重要;一半的患者认为机构化接触、建议和社区分类需求很重要;而对药物治疗、现实接触、救助、情感宣泄、忏悔、社会干预、行政请求等其他请求,只有少数患者(四分之一到三分之一)认为重要。住院医生显著低估了患者对14项请求中10项的重视程度。因素分析证实了患者和治疗师对下层社会患者需求认知存在差异的几个系统性原因。