Tacker W A, Van Vleet J F, Geddes L A
Am Heart J. 1979 Aug;98(2):185-93. doi: 10.1016/0002-8703(79)90220-5.
The safety margin between the strength of shock needed to defibrillate the ventricle and shocks which produce cardiac damage has not previously been reported. This study quantitates the shock intensity required to produce ECG alterations, serum alpha-1LDH and MB CPK isoenzyme elevation and myocardial damage using single transchest damped sinusoidal defibrillator shocks. Shocks of 1 to 20 amperes per Kg. of body weight were applied. Fifty-six dog weighing 2.4 to 15 kilograms were shocked with defibrillator pulses via 10 centimeter diameter electrodes applied to the thorax. Electrocardiograms were taken to be analyzed for arrhythmias, S-T segment changes, and T wave changes. Serum enzyme levels were determined in 25 dogs. Macroscopic and histopathologic studies were conducted on the hearts. Transchest single damped sine wave shocks did not produce microscopically detectable cardiac damage until at least a threefold current overdose was applied. No macroscopic morphologic alterations were observed until at least a sixfold current overdose was applied and no deaths occurred until a twelvefold or greater current overdose was delivered. Incidence and severity of ECG changes, increase in serum enzyme activity, incidence and severity of cardiac damage, and incidence of mortality all correlated positively with shock strength. However, these four adverse effects did not correlate well with each other. Transient ECG changes were very frequent following shock application regardless of the morphologic damage produced, and hence the transient changes have little value as indicators or predictors of damage. Persistent ECG changes were predictive of morphologic changes but were not sensitive enough to detect damage in mildly injured hearts. Likewise, elevated serum cardiac isoenzyme activity was a reliable but insensitive indicator of damage.
以往未曾报道过使心室除颤所需的电击强度与导致心脏损伤的电击强度之间的安全界限。本研究使用经胸单次阻尼正弦波除颤电击,对产生心电图改变、血清α-1乳酸脱氢酶(LDH)和肌酸磷酸激酶(CPK)同工酶升高以及心肌损伤所需的电击强度进行了定量分析。施加的电击强度为每千克体重1至20安培。通过直径为10厘米的电极将除颤脉冲施加于56只体重在2.4至15千克的犬的胸部。记录心电图以分析心律失常、S-T段改变和T波改变。对25只犬测定血清酶水平。对心脏进行大体和组织病理学研究。经胸单次阻尼正弦波电击在至少施加三倍电流过量之前不会产生显微镜下可检测到的心脏损伤。在至少施加六倍电流过量之前未观察到大体形态学改变,在施加十二倍或更大电流过量之前未发生死亡。心电图改变的发生率和严重程度、血清酶活性增加、心脏损伤的发生率和严重程度以及死亡率均与电击强度呈正相关。然而,这四种不良反应之间的相关性并不好。无论产生何种形态学损伤,电击后短暂的心电图改变都非常频繁,因此短暂改变作为损伤的指标或预测指标价值不大。持续性心电图改变可预测形态学改变,但对轻度损伤心脏的损伤检测不够敏感。同样,血清心脏同工酶活性升高是损伤的可靠但不敏感的指标。