Fenwick A
Bull World Health Organ. 1972;47(5):573-8.
On a sugar estate in northern Tanzania, an integrated control programme against Schistosoma mansoni was carried out during the three years 1968-70 inclusive. The costs of that programme are defined, the costs of future snail control in the same area are estimated, and an attempt is made to evaluate the cost-benefit ratio of schistosomiasis control in the estate. The total expenditure on snail control was US $23 538, of which US $17 371 was spent on molluscicides and US $5 135 on labour. This represents an annual expenditure of approximately US $1.31 per estate resident. In the mass diagnosis and treatment campaign the main items in the total expenditure of US $37 043 were labour (US $13 724), drugs (US $4 218), hospital charges (US $8 262), and lost working days (US $8 760). It is estimated that the recurrent annual expenditure necessary to keep S. mansoni at a low level in the future would be US $7 714 on snail control and US $1 832 on detecting and treating new cases; however, the institution of a snail control programme would reduce the need for chemotherapy and would result in recurrent annual savings of US $7 448. In addition, it was estimated from a productivity study that savings of about US $14 000 per year could result if treatment of infected workers raised productivity by 5%. The goodwill that resulted from the protection of wives and children against schistosomiasis would be a further benefit. When all factors are taken into account, snail control appears to be a feasible economic proposition.
在坦桑尼亚北部的一个甘蔗种植园,于1968年至1970年(含)的三年间开展了一项针对曼氏血吸虫的综合防治计划。界定了该计划的成本,估算了同一地区未来灭螺的成本,并尝试评估该种植园血吸虫病防治的成本效益比。灭螺的总支出为23538美元,其中17371美元用于杀螺剂,5135美元用于人工。这相当于每位种植园居民每年约1.31美元的支出。在大规模诊断和治疗行动中,37043美元总支出的主要项目包括人工(13724美元)、药品(4218美元)、医院费用(8262美元)和工作日损失(8760美元)。据估计,未来要将曼氏血吸虫维持在低水平,每年所需的经常性支出为灭螺7714美元以及检测和治疗新病例1832美元;然而,实施灭螺计划将减少化疗需求,并导致每年经常性节省7448美元。此外,根据一项生产力研究估计,如果对受感染工人的治疗使生产力提高5%,每年可节省约14000美元。保护妻子和孩子免受血吸虫病侵害所带来的良好意愿将是进一步的益处。综合考虑所有因素,灭螺似乎是一项可行的经济方案。