Friedman D, Simson R, Ritter W, Rapin I
Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol. 1975 Jan;38(1):13-9. doi: 10.1016/0013-4694(75)90205-9.
Averaged evoked potentials were recorded from PZ and left and right temporo-parietal electodes to real speech words and human sounds in 8 right-handed subjects. Stimuli were presented in a "no task" condition where the subject was instructed to listen attentively, and a vigilance condition where the subject responded to a particular word or sound during a run of such stimuli. The vigilance condition produced two classes of stimuli:signals and non-signals. Evoked potentials to physically identical words or sounds were examined when they were "no task", non-signal and signal stimuli. P300 amplitude increased significantly as a function of increasing task demands going from "no task" to non-signal to signal. When a strict statistical criterion for multiple comparisons (Bonferroni test) was applied in looking for asymmetries between hemispheres, only 2 isolated left greater than right differences turned out to be significant. Review of the literature concerning evoked potential correlates of differential hemispheric processing pointed up flaws in design, statistical technique, and inconsistencies in reported findings which suggested that while evoked potentials may sometimes reflect differences in hemispheric functioning, this effect is marginal at best.
在8名右利手受试者中,记录了从头顶中央(PZ)以及左右颞顶电极对真实语音单词和人类声音的平均诱发电位。刺激呈现于两种条件下:一种是“无任务”条件,即指示受试者专心聆听;另一种是警觉条件,即受试者在一连串此类刺激过程中对特定单词或声音做出反应。警觉条件产生两类刺激:信号和非信号。当物理上相同的单词或声音分别作为“无任务”、非信号和信号刺激时,对其诱发电位进行了检测。随着任务要求从“无任务”到非信号再到信号逐渐增加,P300波幅显著增大。当应用严格的多重比较统计标准(Bonferroni检验)来寻找半球间的不对称性时,仅发现2例孤立的左半球大于右半球的差异具有显著性。对有关半球差异处理的诱发电位相关性的文献综述指出了设计、统计技术方面的缺陷以及报告结果的不一致性,这表明虽然诱发电位有时可能反映半球功能的差异,但这种效应充其量是微不足道的。