Goodwin J S, Goodwin J M, Vogel A V
Ann Intern Med. 1979 Jul;91(1):106-10. doi: 10.7326/0003-4819-91-1-106.
Sixty house officers and 39 registered nurses in a university teaching hospital were surveyed to ascertain their knowledge of placebo action and their patterns of placebo use. The majority of physicians and nurses greatly underestimated the percentage of patients who experience pain relief when given placebo. Placebos typically were given to disliked patients who were suspected of exaggerating their pain or had failed to respond to usual medical regimens, or both. Positive responses to placebo medication were then interpreted by the physicians as evidence that the pain had no physiologic basis. Many studies have shown that overdemanding and complaining patients are, if anything, less likely to respond to placebo than patients well liked by the hospital staff. Nevertheless the results of our survey suggest that this is precisely the type of patient "at risk" for placebo treatment.
我们对一所大学教学医院的60名住院医生和39名注册护士进行了调查,以确定他们对安慰剂作用的了解程度以及使用安慰剂的模式。大多数医生和护士大大低估了服用安慰剂后疼痛得到缓解的患者比例。安慰剂通常给予不受欢迎的患者,这些患者被怀疑夸大疼痛或对常规治疗方案没有反应,或两者皆有。医生们随后将对安慰剂药物的积极反应解释为疼痛没有生理基础的证据。许多研究表明,要求过高且爱抱怨的患者,如果有什么不同的话,比医院工作人员喜欢的患者对安慰剂的反应可能性更小。然而,我们的调查结果表明,这恰恰是接受安慰剂治疗“有风险”的患者类型。