Gray G, Flynn P
Gen Hosp Psychiatry. 1981 Sep;3(3):199-203. doi: 10.1016/0163-8343(81)90002-5.
Two hundred thirty registered nurses and seventy physicians participated in a retrospective study scrutinizing placebo effects, prescribing patterns, and staff attitudes in a university-based general hospital setting. Despite copious experimental literature devoted to placebo effects over the past thirty years, the medical and surgical use of placebos seems to disregard experimental data. Although 80% of the staff had used placebos in the hospital, their knowledge of placebo effects was in many respects deficient. Within the hospital, 89% of placebo use was directed toward the amelioration of "pain"; the authors believe that emphasis should be placed on the education of staff to perceive emotional, social, and physiological concomitants of pain rather than resorting to a purely physicalistic approach. A need to acknowledge staff conflicts over the ethical use of placebos should be a significant part of this educational approach.
230名注册护士和70名医生参与了一项回顾性研究,该研究在一所大学附属医院环境中仔细审查了安慰剂效应、处方模式和工作人员的态度。尽管在过去三十年中有大量关于安慰剂效应的实验文献,但安慰剂在医学和外科中的使用似乎忽视了实验数据。虽然80%的工作人员在医院使用过安慰剂,但他们对安慰剂效应的了解在很多方面都存在不足。在医院内部,89%的安慰剂使用是为了缓解“疼痛”;作者认为,应该强调对工作人员进行教育,使其认识到疼痛的情感、社会和生理伴随因素,而不是采用纯粹的物理方法。承认工作人员在安慰剂的道德使用方面存在冲突的必要性应该是这种教育方法的重要组成部分。