Nutting P A, Barrick J E, Logue S C
J Community Health. 1979 Summer;4(4):267-79. doi: 10.1007/BF01319021.
A typical maternal and child health care program was implemented in an American Indian reservation community, and its impact on the effectiveness of prenatal care was assessed. Evaluation included examination from both the provider perspective (care provided to program users) and the population perspective (care received by a sample of all prenatal patients in the community), as well as examination of outcomes of prenatal care. The study cohorts were sorted into relatively high and average risk as a function of age, gravidity, and history of abortion or miscarriage. The study results suggest that such a program will improve the quality of prenatal care, although the program has a greater impact on the average risk group. Standard methods of assessing program effectiveness, which examine the care provided by the program as opposed to the care received by the community, will not detect this phenomenon.
在美国印第安人保留地社区实施了一项典型的母婴保健项目,并评估了其对产前保健效果的影响。评估包括从提供者角度(为项目使用者提供的护理)和人群角度(社区中所有产前患者样本接受的护理)进行检查,以及对产前保健结果的检查。根据年龄、妊娠次数以及流产或小产史,将研究队列分为相对高风险和平均风险组。研究结果表明,这样一个项目将提高产前保健质量,尽管该项目对平均风险组的影响更大。评估项目有效性的标准方法是检查项目提供的护理,而不是社区接受的护理,这种方法无法检测到这一现象。