Jones E C, Insall J N, Inglis A E, Ranawat C S
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1979 May(140):145-52.
One hundred eight GUEPAR knee arthroplasties have been studied with a follow-up of one year on 41; 2 years on 22 and 3 years on 45 knees. Overall results were 17% excellent, 44% good, 10% fair and 29% poor. Excellent results were comparatively fewer in rheumatoid arthritis. There was a deterioration in the quality of results of arthroplasty with longer follow-up. The incidence of deep infection was 11%. There was a significant correlation between early wound drainage and deep infection. More than half of the infected knees have not required intervenition as yet. One knee was revised and 3 had attempted arthrodesis with one successful fusion. Two patients died with septicemia. Axle migration occurred in 8 knees and femoral stem breakage in 2 knees. Loosening was found in 27% of the knees with progressive reduction in quality of the arthroplasty. Incomplete cementing predisposed to loosening. Patellar symptoms were present in 28% of the knees. Patellar subluxation and dislocation occurred in 49% of the knees. More than half of these were symptomatic. With normal patellofemoral alignment, pain was more common in the osteoarthritic knee. Use of a patellar implant with GUEPAR knee prostesis should be restricted to severely disabled patients with major fixed deformities. Mechanical failure can be minimized by proper positioning of the implant, correct alignment of the extensor mechanism and adequate cement around the entire stem.
对108例GUEPAR膝关节置换术进行了研究,其中41例随访1年,22例随访2年,45例随访3年。总体结果为:优17%,良44%,中10%,差29%。类风湿性关节炎患者的优级结果相对较少。随着随访时间延长,关节置换术的效果质量有所下降。深部感染发生率为11%。早期伤口引流与深部感染之间存在显著相关性。超过一半的感染膝关节尚未需要干预。1例进行了翻修,3例尝试关节融合术,其中1例融合成功。2例患者死于败血症。8例膝关节发生轴移位,2例发生股骨干骨折。27%的膝关节出现松动,关节置换术质量逐渐下降。骨水泥固定不完全易导致松动。28%的膝关节出现髌股症状。49%的膝关节发生髌骨半脱位和脱位,其中一半以上有症状。在髌股对线正常的情况下,疼痛在骨关节炎膝关节中更常见。GUEPAR膝关节假体使用髌骨植入物应仅限于有严重固定畸形的重度残疾患者。通过正确放置植入物、伸直机制的正确对线以及整个柄周围足够的骨水泥,可以将机械故障降至最低。