Shearer R J, Constable A R, Girling M, Hendry W F, Fergusson J D
Br Med J. 1974 May 18;2(5915):362-5. doi: 10.1136/bmj.2.5915.362.
Experience with x-rays, strontium-87m scintigraphy, and technetium-99m polyphosphate scintigraphy in the identification of bone metastases in 201 patients with prostatic cancer is reviewed. About 40% of the patients had demonstrable metastases in bone at the time of first presentation.Comparative studies of 247 x-ray and (87m)Sr surveys indicated that x-rays failed to detect metastases in 10% of cases where they were identified by (87m)Sr but that the isotopic survey similarly failed to detect radiologically evident deposits in 7% of cases.Similar studies comparing (99m)Tc polyphosphate surveys with x-ray scans showed that x-rays missed isotopically detected metastases in 12% of cases, but in only one survey out of 67 did the isotope miss radiologically evident deposits. In a series of 32 patients investigated by both isotopic techniques (99m)Tc polyphosphate did not fail to detect any metastases and identified deposits in one patient in whom they were missed by (87m)Sr scintigraphy. About 15% of both x-ray and (87m)Sr surveys gave equivocal results, but only 3% (2 out of 67) of (99m)Tc polyphosphate surveys were equivocal.We concluded that (99m)Tc polyphosphate bone scintigraphy with the gamma camera was the most reliable of the techniques used for the identification of bone metastases in patients with carcinoma of the prostate. The results of scintigraphy with (87m)Sr suggested that serial surveys may provide early evidence of hormone resistance in prostatic cancer.
回顾了201例前列腺癌患者在骨转移瘤识别中使用X线、锶-87m闪烁扫描法和锝-99m多聚磷酸盐闪烁扫描法的经验。约40%的患者在首次就诊时骨内有可证实的转移瘤。对247次X线检查和(87m)Sr扫描的比较研究表明,X线在(87m)Sr识别出转移瘤的病例中有10%未能检测到,而同位素扫描在7%的病例中同样未能检测到放射学上明显的沉积物。将(99m)Tc多聚磷酸盐扫描与X线扫描进行类似研究表明,X线在同位素检测到转移瘤的病例中有12%漏检,但在67次扫描中只有1次同位素漏检了放射学上明显的沉积物。在一系列32例同时采用两种同位素技术检查的患者中,(99m)Tc多聚磷酸盐未漏检任何转移瘤,且在1例患者中检测到了(87m)Sr闪烁扫描法漏检的沉积物。X线检查和(87m)Sr扫描约15%的结果不明确,但(99m)Tc多聚磷酸盐扫描只有3%(67例中有2例)不明确。我们得出结论,使用γ相机的(99m)Tc多聚磷酸盐骨闪烁扫描法是用于识别前列腺癌患者骨转移瘤的最可靠技术。(87m)Sr闪烁扫描法的结果表明,系列扫描可能为前列腺癌激素抵抗提供早期证据。