Glidden L M, Pawelski C, Mar H, Zigman W
Am J Ment Defic. 1979 Jul;84(1):74-81.
The effect of blocking of stimulus items on the free recall of EMR adolescents was examined. In Experiment 1 a multitrial free-recall list of 15 pictures was presented either simultaneously in groups of 3, or sequentially, one at a time. Consistent ordering was used in both conditions, so that on each trial, each item in each set of 3 pictures was presented contiguously with the other 2 items from that set. In addition, recall came immediately or after a filled or unfilled delay of 24.5 seconds. Results showed that simultaneous presentation led to higher recall, subjective organization, and clustering than did sequential presentation, but analysis of serial-position curves showed a much reduced extended recency effect in comparison with previous studies. Experiment 2 was designed to determine whether the cause of the reduced extended recency was the use of pictures rather than words as stimuli. Stimuli were presented either as pictures, as pictures with auditory labels, or as words with auditory labels, with both simultaneous and consistent ordering for all conditions. Results indicated a strong extended recency effect for all groups, eliminating presentation mode as a causal factor in the data of Experiment 1. We concluded that blocking leads to increased organization and recall over a variety of presentation modes, rates, and block sizes.
研究了对刺激项目进行分组对青少年电子病历自由回忆的影响。在实验1中,15张图片的多次自由回忆列表以3张一组的形式同时呈现,或者依次逐一呈现。在两种条件下都采用了一致的顺序,以便在每次试验中,每组3张图片中的每个项目都与该组中的其他2个项目相邻呈现。此外,回忆在呈现后立即进行,或者在24.5秒的填充或未填充延迟后进行。结果表明,与顺序呈现相比,同时呈现导致更高的回忆率、主观组织和聚类,但系列位置曲线分析显示,与先前的研究相比,延长近因效应大大降低。实验2旨在确定延长近因效应降低的原因是否是使用图片而非单词作为刺激。刺激以图片、带有听觉标签的图片或带有听觉标签的单词的形式呈现,所有条件下均采用同时且一致的顺序。结果表明,所有组都有很强的延长近因效应,排除了呈现模式是实验1数据中的一个因果因素。我们得出结论,分组在各种呈现模式、速率和分组大小下都会导致组织性和回忆率的提高。