Cowley L M, Glen R S
J Clin Psychiatry. 1979 Oct;40(10):411-9.
Forty geriatric patients from the psychiatric ward of a state hospital were enrolled in a 12 week double-blind comparative study of the concentrate forms of thioridazine and haloperidol. The objective of the study was to assess the efficacy and safety of these drugs in the treatment of psychosis associated with organic brain syndrome in the elderly. Two types of patients comprised the population, those who had been hospitalized most of their adult lives and those who had not entered the hospital until late in life. Although both drugs produced significant improvement in these patients' symptoms, the improvement with thioridazine tended to be greater than that with haloperidol in most ratings. A plateau effect was seen with haloperidol in contrast to a steady improvement seen with thioridazine. The safety of both drugs was confirmed. Geriatric patients who display both psychotic and OBS symptomatology were found to respond quite well to both drugs, regardless of their previous psychiatric history, but a somewhat more dramatic response was seen with thioridazine.
一家州立医院精神科病房的40名老年患者参加了一项为期12周的硫利达嗪和氟哌啶醇浓缩剂形式的双盲对照研究。该研究的目的是评估这些药物治疗老年器质性脑综合征相关精神病的疗效和安全性。研究人群包括两类患者,一类是成年后大部分时间都住院的患者,另一类是直到晚年才入院的患者。尽管两种药物都使这些患者的症状有显著改善,但在大多数评分中,硫利达嗪的改善程度往往大于氟哌啶醇。与硫利达嗪持续改善形成对比的是,氟哌啶醇出现了平台效应。两种药物的安全性得到了证实。发现同时表现出精神病和器质性脑综合征症状的老年患者对两种药物的反应都相当良好,无论他们之前的精神病史如何,但硫利达嗪的反应更为显著。