Lancet. 1975 Jul 12;2(7924):45-51.
The efficacy of low-dose heparin in preventing fatal postoperative pulmonary embolism has been investigated in a multicentre prospective randomised trial. 4121 patients over the age of forty years undergoing a variety of elective major surgical procedures were included in the trial; 2076 of these were in the control group and 2045 patients received heparin. The two groups were well matched for age, sex, weight, blood-group, and other factors which could predispose to the development of venous thromboembolism. 180 (4-4 %) patients died during the postoperative period, 100 in the control and 80 in the heparin group: 72% of deaths in the control and 66% in the heparin group had necropsy examination. 16 patients in the control group and 2 in the heparin group were found at necropsy to have died due to acute massive pulmonary embolism (P smaller than 0-005). In addition, emboli found at necropsy in 6 patients in the control group and 3 in the heparin group were considered either contributory to death or an incidental finding since death in these patients was attributed to other causes. Taking all pulmonary emboli together, the findings were again significant (P smaller than 0-005). Of 1292 patients in whom the 125-I-fibrinogen test was performed to detect deep-vein thrombosis (D.V.T.) 667 were in the control group and 625 in the heparin group. The frequency of isotopic D.V.T. was reduced from 24-6% in the control group 7-7% in the heparin group (P smaller 0-005). In 30 patients D.V.T. was detected at necropsy; 24 in the control and 6 in the heparin group (P smaller 0-005). 32 patients in the control group and 11 in the heparin group developed clinically diagnosed D.V.T. which was confirmed by venography (P smaller than 0-005). In addition, 24 patients in the control and 8 in the heparin group were treated for clinically suspected pulmonary emoblism. The difference in the number of patients requiring treatment for D.V.T. and/or pulmonary embolism in the two groups was again significant (P smaller than 0-005). 9 patients were found at necropsy to have died from haemorrhage; 5 were in the control and 4 in the heparin group. A careful objective analysis of operative and postoperative bleeding in 1475 patients showed no statistically significant difference in the blood-transfusion requirements or in the fall in the postoperative haemoglobin level either in the individual operative groups or in the group as a whole. However, the difference in the number of patients who developed wound haematoma in the heparin and control groups was significant (P smaller 0-01). The results of the trial indicate that this form of prophylaxis can now be recommended for use on a large scale in "high-risk" patients undergoing major surgery.
一项多中心前瞻性随机试验对小剂量肝素预防术后致命性肺栓塞的疗效进行了研究。该试验纳入了4121例40岁以上接受各种择期大手术的患者;其中2076例为对照组,2045例患者接受肝素治疗。两组在年龄、性别、体重、血型以及其他可能易导致静脉血栓栓塞形成的因素方面匹配良好。180例(4.4%)患者在术后期间死亡,对照组100例,肝素组80例:对照组72%的死亡病例和肝素组66%的死亡病例进行了尸检。尸检发现对照组16例患者和肝素组2例患者死于急性大面积肺栓塞(P小于0.005)。此外,尸检发现对照组6例患者和肝素组3例患者的栓子被认为要么是导致死亡的原因,要么是偶然发现,因为这些患者的死亡归因于其他原因。将所有肺栓塞病例综合起来看,结果仍然具有显著性(P小于0.005)。在1292例接受125 - I - 纤维蛋白原试验以检测深静脉血栓形成(DVT)的患者中,对照组667例,肝素组625例。同位素检测DVT的频率从对照组的24.6%降至肝素组的7.7%(P小于0.005)。尸检发现30例患者存在DVT;对照组24例,肝素组6例(P小于0.005)。对照组32例患者和肝素组11例患者出现经静脉造影证实的临床诊断DVT(P小于0.005)。此外,对照组24例患者和肝素组8例患者因临床疑似肺栓塞接受了治疗。两组中因DVT和/或肺栓塞需要治疗的患者数量差异再次具有显著性(P小于0.005)。尸检发现9例患者死于出血;对照组5例,肝素组4例。对1475例患者手术及术后出血情况进行的仔细客观分析显示,无论是在各个手术组还是整个组中,输血需求或术后血红蛋白水平下降在统计学上均无显著差异。然而,肝素组和对照组出现伤口血肿的患者数量差异具有显著性(P小于0.01)。试验结果表明,这种预防方式现在可推荐在接受大手术的“高危”患者中大规模使用。