Hamilton J R
Br J Psychiatry. 1979 Jul;135:28-34. doi: 10.1192/bjp.135.1.28.
The progress of 52 chronic alcoholic habitual drunken offenders who were offered a detoxification, assessment and referral service as an alternative to penal management for their public drunkenness was compared over a year with 48 control subjects, and each group's progress in the experimental year was compared with that in the previous year. The 'detoxification' patients were found not to have benefited as regards their alcoholism or episodes of drunkenness, though their periods of abstinence were longer. There were significant improvements in their accommodation and self-reported quality of life, and it is likely that their physical and perhaps mental health improved.
对52名慢性酒精成瘾的惯犯进行了研究,他们被提供了戒毒、评估和转诊服务,作为对其公众醉酒行为进行刑事管理的替代方案。在一年的时间里,将他们的进展与48名对照对象进行了比较,并将每组在实验年的进展与上一年的进展进行了比较。结果发现,“戒毒”患者在酗酒或醉酒发作方面并未受益,尽管他们的戒酒期更长。他们的住宿条件和自我报告的生活质量有了显著改善,而且他们的身体甚至心理健康可能也有所改善。