Narain R, Nair S S, Chandrasekhar P, Rao G R
Bull World Health Organ. 1966;34(4):605-22.
Many problems have to be faced in the estimation of an apparently simple but valuable index-namely, the incidence of tuberculosis infection. Very little attention seems to have been paid to these problems so far.Records from 50 villages in a district of South India, whose populations were tested with 1 TU of PPD RT 23 in Tween 80 diluent and retested after 18 months, have been examined for a reappraisal of existing methods. As a result, it has been found that some of these methods are subject to gross errors and that available figures are unreliable.For estimating the newly infected, a new approach based on the drawing of a curve for the distribution of differences in reaction size from one round of tuberculin testing to another is presented. Further, it is shown that the newly infected probably constitute a homogeneous group with an increase in mean reaction size of about 24 mm and standard deviation of 4 mm. Accordingly, 98% of the newly infected show an increase in reaction size of 16 mm or more. There are others who show similarly large increases in allergy on a retest, even in the absence of infection. The number of persons in the latter category rises with age and is likely to be greater in areas with a high prevalence of non-specific allergy.
在评估一个看似简单却很有价值的指标——即结核感染率时,必须面对许多问题。到目前为止,这些问题似乎很少受到关注。对印度南部一个地区50个村庄的记录进行了检查,这些村庄的人口用含吐温80稀释剂的1个结核菌素单位(TU)的PPD RT 23进行检测,并在18个月后重新检测,目的是重新评估现有方法。结果发现,其中一些方法存在重大误差,现有数据不可靠。为了估计新感染的人数,提出了一种新方法,即绘制一轮结核菌素检测到另一轮结核菌素检测反应大小差异分布的曲线。此外,研究表明,新感染人群可能构成一个同质群体,平均反应大小增加约24毫米,标准差为4毫米。因此,98%的新感染人群反应大小增加16毫米或更多。还有一些人在重新检测时过敏反应也有类似的大幅增加,即使没有感染。后一类人的数量随年龄增长而增加,在非特异性过敏患病率高的地区可能更多。