Narain R, Nair S S, Rao G R, Chandrasekhar P
Bull World Health Organ. 1966;34(4):639-54.
Clinical experience has led to a strong belief that tuberculosis is a family disease and contact examination is a sine qua non for case-finding programmes. Considerable doubts are cast on the usefulness of contact examination in tuberculosis control by the present study, which is based on a sample of an entire population rather than on family contacts of known cases only. Cases of tuberculosis occurred mostly singly in households, and contact examination could have revealed only a very small percentage of the cases in this community.Another common belief is that the prevalence of infection among children under five years of age is a good index of disease in households. In this study, however, a large proportion of households with cases of tuberculosis had no children of this age, and even in homes with a bacteriologically confirmed case, about 88% of the children did not show evidence of infection.The tuberculin reactions of infected contacts were, on the average, slightly larger than those among non-contacts. Further, the proportion of large tuberculin reactions among infected persons was found to be greater in the younger age-groups than in the older age-groups. This finding has been taken to indicate that new infection gives rise to large reactions that subsequently wane to some extent in persons not constantly exposed to infection, such as, for example, the members of households without cases.
临床经验使人们坚信结核病是一种家庭性疾病,接触者检查是病例发现计划的必要条件。本研究基于整个人口样本而非仅已知病例的家庭接触者,对接触者检查在结核病控制中的作用提出了相当大的质疑。结核病病例大多在家庭中单独出现,接触者检查在这个社区中只能发现极少数病例。另一个普遍的观点是,五岁以下儿童的感染率是家庭中疾病的一个良好指标。然而,在本研究中,很大一部分有结核病病例的家庭没有这个年龄段的儿童,即使在有细菌学确诊病例的家庭中,约88%的儿童也没有感染迹象。受感染接触者的结核菌素反应平均略大于非接触者。此外,发现受感染人群中结核菌素强反应的比例在较年轻年龄组中比在较年长年龄组中更高。这一发现被认为表明新感染会引发强反应,随后在未持续接触感染的人群(如没有病例的家庭中的成员)中会在一定程度上减弱。