Hakama M, Pukkala E, Saastamoinen P
J Epidemiol Community Health. 1979 Dec;33(4):257-61. doi: 10.1136/jech.33.4.257.
Using data taken from the organised mass screening system in Finland, risk indicators of cervical cancer were identified in order to define a high-risk group which could then be used for selective screening of cervical cancer. Single risk factors classified at best 39% of the cases into a high-risk group of 8%. A combination of risk factors by different statistical methods was applied, but the results were essentially the same. In order to find a high-risk group small enough to yield a reduction in costs, the number of cases originating from the low-risk group was increased. Theoretical calculations showed that for selective screening to be effective, the risk of disease in the high-risk group relative to that in the low-risk group must be greater than that implied by current knowledge of cervical cancer epidemiology. It was concluded that selective screening has only a limited applicability.
利用从芬兰有组织的大规模筛查系统获取的数据,确定了宫颈癌的风险指标,以便界定一个高危人群,进而用于宫颈癌的选择性筛查。单一风险因素最多只能将39%的病例归入8%的高危人群。应用了不同统计方法对风险因素进行组合,但结果基本相同。为了找到一个足够小的高危人群以降低成本,增加了低危人群中的病例数量。理论计算表明,要使选择性筛查有效,高危人群中的疾病风险相对于低危人群必须大于当前宫颈癌流行病学知识所暗示的风险。得出的结论是,选择性筛查的适用性有限。