Rodgerson M J, Wiseman B L, Ford W E
Curr Alcohol. 1979;7:149-59.
In this study, it was hypothesized that community mental health centers (CMHCs) with distinct alcoholism treatment programs (ATPs) would diagnose alcohol problems at a greater frequency than would centers without ATPs. It was also hypothesized that psychoses, personality disorders, and transient situational disturbances would be diagnosed more frequently in CMHCs without ATPs. Yearly diagnostic admission data from nine of Nebraska's CMHCs (four with ATPs, five without) were used. It was found that CMHCs with ATPs diagnosed significantly more alcohol problems than did CMHCs without ATPs (23.5% vs 4.2%). In addition, it was found that CMHCs with ATPs diagnosed significantly lower totals of transient situational disturbances than did CMHCs without ATPs. No differences were found between CMHCs on totals of other diagnostic categories. Practical implications and several alternative explanations for the findings are discussed.
在本研究中,研究人员提出假设:拥有独特酒精成瘾治疗项目(ATP)的社区心理健康中心(CMHC)诊断出酒精问题的频率会高于没有ATP的中心。研究人员还假设,在没有ATP的CMHC中,精神病、人格障碍和短暂情境性障碍的诊断频率会更高。研究使用了内布拉斯加州9个CMHC的年度诊断入院数据(4个有ATP,5个没有)。研究发现,有ATP的CMHC诊断出的酒精问题明显多于没有ATP的CMHC(23.5%对4.2%)。此外,研究发现,有ATP的CMHC诊断出的短暂情境性障碍总数明显低于没有ATP的CMHC。在其他诊断类别总数方面,CMHC之间未发现差异。文中讨论了研究结果的实际意义和几种替代解释。