Gray G E, Gray L K
JPEN J Parenter Enteral Nutr. 1979 Sep-Oct;3(5):366-8. doi: 10.1177/014860717900300509.
To assess the validity of standards for weight, arm circumference, triceps skinfold, and arm muscle circumference commonly used to assess the nutritional status of hospitalized patients, these standards were applied to data for the normal U.S. population. Moderate depletion was defined as a value between 60 and 90 percent of the standard; severe depletion was defined as a value below 60 percent of the standard. The standards themselves were found to differ substantially from the population averages, and this method of classifying an individual does not take into account the fact that there is more variation in the population for some measures than for others. As a result, the proportion of individuals classified as depleted varied greatly between measures and also between sexes and ages. Over half of all young women would be classified as moderately depleted based on the arm muscle circumference. Over half of young men would be classified as depleted based on the tricep skinfold, and half of these would be classified as severely depleted. It is recommended that the use of these standards and this method of interpretation be abandoned and replaced by the use of tables of percentiles for the U.S. population.
为评估常用于评估住院患者营养状况的体重、上臂围、三头肌皮褶厚度和上臂肌肉围标准的有效性,将这些标准应用于美国正常人群的数据。中度消耗定义为标准值的60%至90%之间;重度消耗定义为低于标准值的60%。发现这些标准本身与人群平均值有很大差异,而且这种对个体进行分类的方法没有考虑到某些测量指标在人群中的变异比其他指标更大这一事实。因此,被归类为消耗的个体比例在不同测量指标之间以及不同性别和年龄之间差异很大。基于上臂肌肉围,超过一半的年轻女性会被归类为中度消耗。基于三头肌皮褶厚度,超过一半的年轻男性会被归类为消耗,其中一半会被归类为重度消耗。建议放弃使用这些标准和这种解释方法,转而使用美国人群的百分位数表。