Karumo I
Ann Chir Gynaecol. 1977;66(1):41-6.
Fifty six meniscectomy patients were divided into 2 groups. One group (27 patients) was given the standard postoperative physiotherapy and the remainder (29 patients) received intensive physiotherapy. Clinical examination of the knee joint was performed preoperatively and 1, 2 and 4 weeks postoperatively. The patients' age was 36.26 +/- 12.34 and 34.00 +/- 9.21 years in the two groups respectively. The medial meniscus was removed from 47 patients, the lateral meniscus from 8 patients and bilateral meniscectomy was performed on one patient; no tear was seen in the excised meniscus in 8 cases. The clinical findings for the patient groups did not differ significantly either before or after the operation. The flexion strength of the knee of patients given intensive physiotherapy increased less in these 4 weeks than the flexion strength of the routine therapy group. The range of knee movement of the patients given intensive therapy was still below the preoperative value 4 weeks after the operation. Knee punctures were made more frequently on patients given intensive physiotherapy. Their walking capacity 2 weeks postoperatively was inferior to that of patients given routine physiotherapy, but this difference had disappeared at the 4-week examination. The isometric quadriceps strength and isotonic strength correlated well. The thigh girth gave no evidence of quadriceps atrophy. It can be concluded that intensified physiotherapy in meniscectomy patients does not shorten the rehabilitation period.
56例半月板切除术患者被分为2组。一组(27例患者)接受标准术后物理治疗,其余(29例患者)接受强化物理治疗。术前以及术后1周、2周和4周对膝关节进行临床检查。两组患者的年龄分别为36.26±12.34岁和34.00±9.21岁。47例患者切除内侧半月板,8例患者切除外侧半月板,1例患者接受双侧半月板切除术;8例切除的半月板未见撕裂。两组患者术前和术后的临床结果均无显著差异。接受强化物理治疗的患者膝关节屈曲力量在这4周内的增加幅度小于常规治疗组的屈曲力量。接受强化治疗的患者术后4周膝关节活动范围仍低于术前值。接受强化物理治疗的患者膝关节穿刺更频繁。他们术后2周的行走能力不如接受常规物理治疗的患者,但在4周检查时这种差异已消失。等长股四头肌力量和等张力量相关性良好。大腿围没有显示股四头肌萎缩的迹象。可以得出结论,半月板切除术患者的强化物理治疗不会缩短康复期。