Grover P L, Miller J
Public Health Rep. 1976 May-Jun;91(3):249-53.
The results of a number of studies which have indicated the limited effectiveness of health education efforts using the mass media are reviewed. The cause of these failures, according to the authors was the inability to apply a number of principles of effective design to the instructional materials used in the mass media. The basic slide show produced by the neighborhood health center for its own population may be more effective than a nationally televised spot announcement because locally prepared material can be sharply focused on the learner's characteristics and the specifically desired outcome behavior. The authors list 10 guidelines for the construction of effective instructional materials: define outcome measures, analyze relevant characteristics of the learner, gain and maintain the learner's attention, establish the learner's vulnerability, demonstrate the needs for action, establish the learner as an agent, establish the learner's effectiveness, provide for practice, repeat key facts, and generalize to similar situations. The principles of social reinforcement that must accompany health education instruction if behavior is to be modified are outlined. How environmental factors such as time, distance, expense, and the organization of health services hamper desired behavior outcomes is also discussed.
回顾了多项研究结果,这些研究表明利用大众媒体开展的健康教育成效有限。据作者称,这些失败的原因在于无法将一些有效设计原则应用于大众媒体所使用的教学材料。社区健康中心为其自身人群制作的基本幻灯片展示可能比全国性电视插播广告更有效,因为本地制作的材料可以紧密围绕学习者的特点以及具体期望的结果行为。作者列出了构建有效教学材料的10条指导原则:定义结果衡量标准、分析学习者的相关特征、吸引并保持学习者的注意力、确定学习者的易感性、展示行动的必要性、将学习者确立为行动者、确立学习者的效能、提供练习机会、重复关键事实以及推广到类似情况。概述了如果要改变行为,健康教育指导必须伴随的社会强化原则。还讨论了时间、距离、费用和卫生服务组织等环境因素如何阻碍期望的行为结果。