Glick S D, Ross D A, Hough L B
Brain Res. 1982 Feb 18;234(1):53-63. doi: 10.1016/0006-8993(82)90472-3.
Data recently published as indicating little or no evidence of neurotransmitter asymmetries in post-mortem human brain were analyzed by correlational and Chi-square procedures. Although handedness data were not available and it was not possible to determine the functional significance of asymmetries, our analysis shows that asymmetries in several brain structures and transmitter systems do indeed exist. The major findings are: (1) correlations of left-right asymmetries between and within structures and transmitters yielded a non-random distribution of significant correlations; (2) left-right asymmetries in glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD) and gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) were positively correlated in all 9 structures examined; (3) correlations between left-right asymmetries of different neurotransmitters within the same structure tended to be positive whereas correlations between different structures tended to be negative: both trends were significant; (4) choline acetyltransferase (ChAT) and dopamine (DA) were both significantly left-biased, by Chi-square tests, in globus pallidus; left-right asymmetries in ChAT and DA were positively correlated in globus pallidus, as well as in caudate nucleus and putamen; (5) left-right asymmetries in ChAT and GAD were positively correlated in all cortical areas and negatively correlated in all nigrostriatal structures; (6) in caudate, putamen and globus pallidus, there was a significant trend for brains with lower dopamine levels to be left-biased and vice-versa; (7) there was a highly significant inverse correlation of age with the absolute asymmetry in globus pallidus ChAT; (8) correlations of absolute asymmetries between the same or different neurotransmitters in different structures were usually positive, indicating that a greater or lesser degree of asymmetry probably characterizes each particular brain; (9) lastly, there were several similarities between the human data and those previously reported in rats, demonstrating that studies in the rat may reveal mechanisms and functions of brain asymmetry that are relevant to man.
通过相关性分析和卡方检验程序,对最近发表的数据进行了分析,这些数据表明在死后人类大脑中几乎没有或没有神经递质不对称的证据。尽管没有利手数据,也无法确定不对称的功能意义,但我们的分析表明,几个脑结构和递质系统中确实存在不对称。主要发现如下:(1) 结构和递质之间以及内部左右不对称的相关性产生了显著相关性的非随机分布;(2) 在所有9个检查的结构中,谷氨酸脱羧酶(GAD)和γ-氨基丁酸(GABA)的左右不对称呈正相关;(3) 同一结构内不同神经递质的左右不对称之间的相关性往往为正,而不同结构之间的相关性往往为负:两种趋势均显著;(4) 通过卡方检验,胆碱乙酰转移酶(ChAT)和多巴胺(DA)在苍白球中均显著偏向左侧;ChAT和DA的左右不对称在苍白球以及尾状核和壳核中呈正相关;(5) ChAT和GAD的左右不对称在所有皮质区域呈正相关,而在所有黑质纹状体结构中呈负相关;(6) 在尾状核、壳核和苍白球中,多巴胺水平较低的大脑有显著的向左偏趋势,反之亦然;(7) 年龄与苍白球ChAT的绝对不对称呈高度显著的负相关;(8) 不同结构中相同或不同神经递质之间的绝对不对称的相关性通常为正,表明每个特定大脑可能具有或多或少的不对称特征;(9) 最后,人类数据与先前在大鼠中报道的数据有几个相似之处,表明对大鼠的研究可能揭示与人类相关的脑不对称机制和功能。