Br Med J (Clin Res Ed). 1984 Sep 8;289(6445):601-3. doi: 10.1136/bmj.289.6445.601.
In a prospective multicentre study of gastric adenocarcinoma the problem of microscopic disease at the resection line was investigated. Of 390 patients with resected gastric cancer, 85 (22%) had disease of the resection margins--32 at the oesophagus, 20 at the gastric margin, 17 at the duodenum, and six at both margins (10 were unspecified). Some 105 resections were considered palliative and 285 curative; 39 and 46 respectively had resection line disease. When resection margin clearance had been achieved a significantly improved survival was found, both overall (p = 0.0001), in the curative group (p = 0.0009), and in those with serosal disease but no microscopic disease of the lymph nodes (p = 0.0109). When the resection margin was diseased the survival rate for TNM stage IIS fell to that of stage IVA; 16% of those having curative surgery had had inadequate resections. The results of this study show that microscopic disease at the resection line influences long term survival and that surgeons should ensure that resection lines are clear. It also shows that the classification of patients who have resection line disease should be downgraded to stage IVA in the TNM staging system and they should be considered to have had only a palliative resection.
在一项关于胃腺癌的前瞻性多中心研究中,对切除边缘的微小病灶问题进行了调查。在390例接受胃癌切除术的患者中,85例(22%)存在切除边缘病灶——32例位于食管,20例位于胃边缘,17例位于十二指肠,6例在两个边缘(10例未明确)。约105例切除被认为是姑息性的,285例是根治性的;分别有39例和46例存在切除边缘病灶。当实现切除边缘切缘阴性时,总体生存率(p = 0.0001)、根治性切除组(p = 0.0009)以及有浆膜侵犯但无淋巴结微小病灶的患者(p = 0.0109)均有显著改善。当切除边缘有病灶时,TNM分期II期患者的生存率降至IVA期水平;接受根治性手术的患者中有16%切除不充分。本研究结果表明,切除边缘的微小病灶会影响长期生存,外科医生应确保切除边缘清晰。研究还表明,在TNM分期系统中,存在切除边缘病灶的患者应降级为IVA期,且应认为他们仅接受了姑息性切除。