Moilanen A
Rofo. 1982 Aug;137(2):129-35. doi: 10.1055/s-2008-1056175.
The accuracy in reading of primary maxillo-facial films of 347 inpatients with facial fractures was analysed retrospectively. In all, patients had 438 fractures: 116 nasal, 167 mandibular, 133 mid-facial and 22 upper facial fractures. 68% of all patients were operated. A correct diagnosis in the accident department was made in 322 out of 438 fractures (74%) by a radiologist and in 294 (70%) by a non-radiologist. The accuracy in interpretation of nasal and mandibular fractures was good by both interpreters, but less satisfactory in the assessment of mid-facial fractures. A false diagnosis was made in 23% of cases by a radiologist and in 24% by a non-radiologist, a partially correct diagnosis in 32% and in 42% of cases, respectively. Poor radiographic technique and lack of experience for facial trauma diagnostics from a radiological aspect were the most important sources of error. In general hospitals, special training in the interpretation of maxillo-facial radiograms should be organized.
对347例面部骨折住院患者的初次颌面X光片读片准确性进行了回顾性分析。患者共有438处骨折:116处鼻骨骨折、167处下颌骨骨折、133处面中部骨折和22处上颌骨骨折。所有患者中有68%接受了手术。放射科医生在438处骨折中的322处(74%)以及非放射科医生在294处(70%)做出了正确诊断。两位读片者对鼻骨和下颌骨骨折的解读准确性良好,但对面中部骨折的评估不太令人满意。放射科医生在23%的病例中做出了错误诊断,非放射科医生在24%的病例中做出了错误诊断,分别在32%和42%的病例中做出了部分正确诊断。放射技术不佳以及从放射学角度对面部创伤诊断缺乏经验是最重要的错误来源。在综合医院,应组织颌面X光片解读方面的专项培训。