Romski M A, Ruder K F
J Speech Hear Disord. 1984 Aug;49(3):293-302. doi: 10.1044/jshd.4903.293.
This study was designed to compare the effects of speech and speech-plus-sign stimulation during comprehension treatment on the oral language learning and generalization of action + object relational meanings. Ten home-reared Down's syndrome children in Early Stage 1 received concurrent comprehension treatment in Speech and Speech-Sign conditions using a miniature linguistic system. Upon attainment of criterion level performance in both conditions, generalization tasks were administered to measure the effects of the comprehension treatment on the comprehension and the production of treated and untreated action + object combinations. The results obtained from this study indicated that the two treatment conditions did not differ significantly for either learning or generalization. The data did, however, indicate that individual patterns of acquisition were evident among the children. Caution is advised concerning the automatic adoption or rejection of manual sign as part of oral language intervention programs.
本研究旨在比较在理解治疗过程中,言语刺激与言语加手势刺激对动作+物体关系意义的口语学习及泛化的影响。十名处于第一早期阶段的家庭养育唐氏综合征儿童,使用微型语言系统在言语和言语-手势条件下接受同步理解治疗。在两种条件下达到标准水平表现后,进行泛化任务,以测量理解治疗对已治疗和未治疗的动作+物体组合的理解及产出的影响。本研究获得的结果表明,两种治疗条件在学习或泛化方面均无显著差异。然而,数据确实表明儿童中存在明显的个体习得模式。对于将手势自动纳入或排除在口语干预计划中,建议谨慎对待。