Brown J E, McLeod A A, Shand D G
Clin Pharmacol Ther. 1983 Apr;33(4):424-8. doi: 10.1038/clpt.1983.57.
We compared the effects of single doses of 50 mg atenolol (cardioselective), 40 mg propranolol (nonselective), and placebo on both exercise- and isoproterenol-induced tachycardia in two experiments involving nine normal subjects. Maximal exercise heart rate was reduced from 187 +/- 4(SEM) after placebo to 146 +/- 7 bpm after atenolol and 138 +/- 6 bpm after propranolol, but there were no differences between the drugs. The effects on isoproterenol tachycardia were determined before and after atropine (0.04 mg/kg IV). Isoproterenol sensitivity was determined as the intravenous dose that increased heart rate by 25 bpm (CD25) and this was increased from 1.8 +/- 0.3 micrograms after placebo to 38.9 +/- 8.3 micrograms after propranolol and 8.3 +/- 1.7 micrograms after atenolol. The difference in the effects of the two was significant. After atropine the CD25 was unchanged after placebo (2.3 +/- 0.3 micrograms) and atenolol (7.7 +/- 1.3 micrograms); it was reduced after propranolol (24.8 +/- 5.0 micrograms), but remained different from atenolol. This change with propranolol sensitivity was calculated as the apparent Ka, this was unchanged by atropine (11.7 +/- 2.1 and 10.1 +/- 2.5 ml/ng). These data are consistent with the hypothesis that exercise-induced tachycardia results largely from beta 1-receptor activation that is blocked by both cardioselective and nonselective drugs, whereas isoproterenol activates both beta 1- and beta 2-receptors so that after cardioselective blockade there remains a beta 2-component that can be blocked with a nonselective drug. While there appear to be beta 2-receptors in the human heart, their physiologic or pathologic roles remain to be defined.
在两项涉及9名正常受试者的实验中,我们比较了单次服用50毫克阿替洛尔(心脏选择性)、40毫克普萘洛尔(非选择性)和安慰剂对运动诱发及异丙肾上腺素诱发心动过速的影响。最大运动心率在服用安慰剂后为187±4(标准误)次/分钟,服用阿替洛尔后降至146±7次/分钟,服用普萘洛尔后降至138±6次/分钟,但两种药物之间无差异。在静脉注射阿托品(0.04毫克/千克)前后测定对异丙肾上腺素诱发心动过速的影响。异丙肾上腺素敏感性以使心率增加25次/分钟的静脉注射剂量(CD25)来确定,该剂量在服用安慰剂后为1.8±0.3微克,服用普萘洛尔后增至38.9±8.3微克,服用阿替洛尔后为8.3±1.7微克。两者作用的差异具有显著性。注射阿托品后,安慰剂组(2.3±0.3微克)和阿替洛尔组(7.7±1.3微克)的CD25未变;普萘洛尔组(24.8±5.0微克)的CD25降低,但仍与阿替洛尔组不同。普萘洛尔敏感性的这种变化以表观解离常数(Ka)计算,阿托品对此无影响(分别为11.7±2.1和10.1±2.5毫升/纳克)。这些数据与以下假设一致:运动诱发的心动过速主要源于β1受体激活,心脏选择性和非选择性药物均可阻断该激活;而异丙肾上腺素同时激活β1和β2受体,因此在心脏选择性阻断后,仍存在可被非选择性药物阻断的β2成分。虽然人类心脏中似乎存在β2受体,但其生理或病理作用仍有待确定。